Best Used Cars and SUVs for Less Than $5,000

These models have strong reliability and performed well in CR's tests

By Jon Linkov

There’s no reason for any car buyer to have to settle for an unreliable or dangerous vehicle just because their budget is tight. Many models that were smart choices when they were new still have those same good qualities years later as older, much less expensive used cars.

And, yes, even used cars under $5,000 can offer high-quality and reliable transportation. They were good when we recommended them as new, and now, years later—more than a decade in most cases—they’ve held up.

Below, we have the most reliable used cars available for $5,000 or less. The top choices came with standard electronic stability control (ESC), a safety system that saves lives and is now required on all new cars. We also included models where ESC was available as an option, and the ones that did not offer it at all.

This article is free, though only CR members will see full ratings for each vehicle below. Plus, when CR members search our Used Car Marketplace for vehicles for sale in their area, they will see a reliability and owner satisfaction rating for each listing.

Small Cars

Honda Insight 2010

Honda directly targeted the Toyota Prius with the second-generation Insight hatchback, but it turned out to be a half-hearted effort. Its fuel economy of 39 mpg overall isn’t up to the standards of other small hybrids. Driving the Insight is no prize either, because it is slow and noisy. Base LX versions lacked electronic stability control; emergency handling was a handful. Look for a model built with the optional electronic stability control. Interior fit and finish is lacking, rear visibility is difficult, and the back seat is cramped.

Mazda3 2012

The Mazda3 was one of our top-scoring small cars. It is gifted with agile handling and a well-laid-out passenger compartment built with quality materials. The rear seating area is snug, and road noise is somewhat pronounced. Stability control became standard in the 2011 model year. For 2012, Mazda added a new 2.0-liter engine that boosted fuel economy to an impressive 32 mpg with the six-speed automatic. A blind-spot detection system was also available that year.

SUVs

Honda Pilot 2004, 2006

The three-row Pilot has seating for up to eight passengers and offers available all-wheel drive. The slick V6 delivers punchy performance, yet respectable fuel economy of 18 mpg overall. The Pilot also serves up a comfortable ride in combination with secure handling. Pronounced road noise makes it a rather loud vehicle, especially on grooved pavement or concrete slabs. There’s little room behind the raised third-row seat. The interior is simple but well put together and features lots of cubbies and bins. Look for an EX version with leather, which holds up over time better than cloth. Get a 2006 or newer version, if you can, because it has standard stability control.

Nissan Rogue 2012

The first-generation Rogue has a handy and compact size, but that comes at the expense of cargo capacity, and the sleek styling impedes the view aft. We suggest that you look for a Rogue with the optional rear-view camera. The 170-hp, 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine sounded a bit raspy at high revs but averaged a respectable 22 mpg. The continuously variable transmission (CVT) worked well. The Rogue’s ride quality is supple, and its handling is fairly nimble. Most controls and buttons are large and simple to operate. However, the climate controls are mounted low and there is no radio-tuning knob.

Toyota Highlander 2002, 2004

Well rounded and pleasant, the Toyota Highlander has long been an excellent choice. This midsized SUV offered front- or all-wheel drive, and a V6 or four-cylinder engine. Look for a 2004 model, which had standard electronic stability control and was available with an optional third-row seat and a more powerful V6. Expect 19 mpg overall. Quiet, roomy, and relaxing to drive, the Highlander has a very comfortable ride and easy-to-use controls. Access is easy, and outward visibility is excellent.

Models With Optional ESC

All of these sedans, hatchbacks, and SUVs were available with ESC in the model years listed, either as an option or standard on certain trim levels.

Models Without ESC

These reliable models were not available with ESC in the model years listed.

Consumer Reports is an independent, nonprofit organization that works side by side with consumers to create a fairer, safer, and healthier world. CR does not endorse products or services, and does not accept advertising. Copyright © 2025, Consumer Reports, Inc.