The Chevrolet Impala name dates back to 1958, and for many families it meant the big, comfortable Chevy in the driveway. The best ones still fill car-show fields. Yet a nameplate that lasts that long also picks up some lean years. Some Impalas arrived just as emissions rules choked big engines. Others were front-drive sedans that shared little with the cars that made the name famous. A few spent their lives in rental lots and fleet yards, and it shows. These are our picks, five Impalas we would think twice about buying, and why. The verdicts are our opinion. However, every complaint count, recall, horsepower figure and build number comes from the records and references linked in the list. 1. 2002 Chevrolet Impala LS The Impala returned for 2000 as a front-wheel-drive sedan on the W-body platform it shared with the Lumina. The base car used a 180 hp 3.4-liter V6. By comparison, the LS stepped up to a 200 hp 3.8-liter V6, and the 2002 LS in our photo is that car. The trouble is in the gaskets. CarComplaints.com logs 142 complaints about intake manifold gasket failure and coolant leaks on the 2002 Impala. Owners report a typical repair cost of $820 at an average of 89,500 miles. There is a second gasket issue on the 3.8 itself. According to a used-vehicle review on AutoTrader.ca, a Canadian recall covered 128,726 Impalas from 2000 to 2003. Degraded front rocker cover gaskets could drip oil onto the exhaust manifold, which created a fire risk. Our take: the 3.8 is the better engine of the two, and the same reviewer calls it durable. Still, we’d pass on a 2002 unless the paperwork shows the gaskets and the recall were handled. That is a long way from what made the name famous, as our look at why the Impala became America’s favorite family car shows. If you buy one anyway, check the coolant level and the oil around the exhaust before money changes hands. 2. 2006 Chevrolet Impala LS 3.5L The ninth-generation Impala launched for 2006, and the LS came with a new 3.5-liter V6 rated at 211 hp. It replaced the old 3.4. On paper, that looks like progress. In practice, the 3.5 has a list of leak points. AutoTrader.ca’s reviewer warns that it may leak from the oil pan gasket, the crank seals, the crossover coolant pipes and the oil filter adapter. In addition, a technical service bulletin covers leaking cylinder head gaskets on both the 3.5 and the 3.9. The generation also drew a lawsuit. In 2011, owners of 2007 and 2008 Impalas sued GM over rear alignment problems that wore out tires early, as GM Authority reported. The named plaintiff said her tires were finished after only 6,000 miles. GM had issued a service bulletin for police Impalas in 2008, but it said the civilian car was different. Our take: the 2006 isn’t named in that suit, but it shares the same basic leak list. We’d steer clear unless the engine is dry underneath. Buyer advice: crawl under it with a flashlight, and ask for proof of any head gasket work. 3. 1978 Chevrolet Impala coupe Chevrolet downsized its full-size cars for 1977, and the result was shorter, taller and narrower than before. Even so, the new Impala gained headroom. The 1977 to 1979 coupes also had a distinctive double-bent, tempered rear window, and Chevrolet built 60,072 coupes for 1978. The weak spot is what sat under the hood of a base car. Chevrolet brought back an inline six for the downsized Impala, rated at just 110 hp. That’s a modest figure for a full-size coupe, even a lighter one. By contrast, the 305 V8 was on the options list, and it makes far more sense today. The design deserves credit, and the coupe’s bent rear glass still looks sharp. Yet a six-cylinder 1978 coupe feels like a car built to meet a fuel target, not to please a driver. For a broader tour of the oddballs, see 11 Impalas you forgot existed. Our take: we’d skip the six-cylinder car. Buyer advice: check the engine code before you fall for the rear window, and hold out for a V8 coupe. 4. 1976 Chevrolet Impala The 1976 Impala was the end of the old big-car era, and it was enormous. It measured 222.9 inches long on a 121.5-inch wheelbase. That year it borrowed the previous Caprice nose with a new egg-crate grille. It was also the last year for the four-door hardtop and the clamshell wagon tailgate. The engines tell the story. A 350 two-barrel V8 had been the standard engine since 1973. Catalytic converters arrived for 1975, and engines were designed for unleaded fuel from 1972. As a result, the optional 454 made 225 hp in 1976, down from 365 hp in 1971. Sales were already slipping. In 1975, the Impala sold 176,376 units, the weakest result since its 1958 introduction. For 1976, Chevrolet also added a cheaper Impala S sedan aimed at fleet buyers. Our take: we’d pass on a 1976 if you want performance, because it is a lot of car for little go. It can still make a relaxed cruiser. Buyer advice: if power matters, look at the 1971 cars instead, and budget for fuel either way. 5. 2016 Chevrolet Impala Limited LT When Chevrolet launched the new 2014 Impala, it kept the old car alive under another name. According to Automotive Fleet, GM built the Impala Limited for rental, corporate and government fleets through the 2016 model year. GM’s own order guide, as GM Authority reported, barred retail buyers entirely. The fleet numbers explain where these cars went. In 2012, 78.3% of Impalas sold went to fleets, and rental companies registered 115,880 of them. In other words, a used Impala Limited almost certainly spent its first years as a rental, a sales-rep car or a government sedan. The car underneath dated back to 2006. The later cars did get a 3.6-liter V6 and a six-speed automatic for 2012. Still, AutoTrader.ca notes that this generation’s brake rotors are prone to warping, and pads wear early. Those are just the wear items a hard-driven fleet car uses up. Police versions are a different story, as our look at the Caprice 9C1 police package shows. Our take: we’d avoid a Limited unless it comes with full service records. Buyer advice: check the brakes and tires closely, and walk away from a car with no history. The ninth generation ran for eight model years before the Limited carried it to the end of production in 2016.