Autoblog and Yahoo may earn commission from links in this article.AI's Growing Role In CarsAI is being integrated into the automotive industry in many ways. Brands like Audi are using AI to improve production processes, while General Motors wants the technology to help shorten vehicle development from the usual four to six years to just two.In showrooms, AI is also being used for customer service, including chatbots. For one BMW dealership in Toronto, however, that backfired after its AI agent offered to buy back what appears to be a 2021 X3 for far more than the dealer reportedly intended to pay. According to CBC News, the dealership later agreed to honor the AI-generated offer after media scrutiny.The Buyback TwistWhat happened was that the owner, Zack Giacomelli, wanted to sell his BMW X3 back to BMW Toronto after the vehicle required major repairs. Giacomelli contacted "Quinn," whom he did not know was an AI chatbot at the time, about selling the SUV. The chatbot then offered him CAD 27,162.79 (approximately $19,400 at current exchange rates) for the vehicle – the exact amount remaining on his loan – which he accepted.AdvertisementAdvertisementA BMW Toronto sales consultant later contacted Giacomelli to inform him that Quinn was an AI agent and that the offer had been reduced to CAD 20,000 ($14,200) instead. Giacomelli said he felt "devastated" by the situation but argued that the dealership should honor the AI-generated offer because the chatbot was acting in place of a dealership employee.After CBC News contacted BMW Toronto, the dealership reinstated the original offer, with sales manager Scott Shadbolt saying it was the right thing to do for Giacomelli. Shadbolt also explained that the AI had mistakenly treated Giacomelli's remaining loan balance on the X3 as the vehicle's buyback value, and that the dealership would rely only on human employees for such transactions moving forward.BMWThe Bigger QuestionIt is worth noting that, as with most dealership-manufacturer relationships, BMW Toronto operates independently of BMW, meaning the chatbot error and subsequent buyback dispute were the dealership's responsibility rather than the German automaker's.Nevertheless, the case shows how risky AI can be when it is used in customer-facing parts of a business. AI adoption feels inevitable at this point, so much so that BMW itself is already using AI-powered humanoid robots called AEON at its Leipzig plant in Germany. So perhaps the challenge is how well companies manage and oversee it.BMWView the 3 images of this gallery on the original articleAdvertisementAdvertisementThis story was originally published by Autoblog on Jun 14, 2026, where it first appeared in the News section. Add Autoblog as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
+56 others
