It was an unprecedented incident: in February, a dispute erupted at Tesla’s Grünheide plant after a representative of the IG Metall trade union allegedly recorded a works council meeting on his laptop. When this was discovered, the meeting was abruptly ended, security was called in, and even the police were summoned – who confiscated the union rep’s laptop.

The incident occurred ahead of the contentious works council elections at Tesla, which were ultimately won not by IG Metall but by the ‘Giga United‘ list, considered close to the company.

However, the dispute over the alleged laptop recording of the works council meeting is still ongoing. The Local Court of Fürstenwalde/Spree has now issued a penalty order against Tesla plant manager André Thierig for defamation. He is to pay a fine of 80 daily rates. This penalty order was requested by the Frankfurt (Oder) Public Prosecutor’s Office following a criminal complaint filed by IG Metall.

Thierig, however, has lodged an objection and is therefore considered innocent until a corresponding court ruling. As a result, the case will proceed to a public trial.

To this day, both sides continue to contest the interpretation of the alleged incident during the February works council meeting. At the time, plant manager Thierig publicised the event in an internal employee email and in a post on X: “For unknown reasons, he recorded the internal meeting and was caught red-handed!” Thierig wrote.

However, the Public Prosecutor’s Office found no such recording on the laptop. Soon afterwards, IG Metall, Tesla, and Thierig reached a settlement (DE) at the Frankfurt (Oder) Labour Court.

Yet the conflict persists: IG Metall has filed a criminal complaint against Tesla’s plant manager for ‘defamation’, leading to the current penalty order. Tesla, for its part, maintains its position, arguing that the union representative may have recorded the meeting via WhatsApp in the browser on his laptop, leaving no traces of the recording on the device itself.

handelsblatt.com (DE)