For many parents, handing over the keys to a newly licensed teenager can be more stressful than teaching them how to drive in the first place. While experience ultimately comes with time behind the wheel, choosing the right vehicle can significantly reduce the risks young drivers face on the road.That's why the annual list of recommended vehicles for teen drivers from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and Consumer Reports has become such an important resource for families across America. The 2026 edition is out, and one automaker stands out from the crowd: Subaru.The Japanese brand earned nine spots on the updated recommendation list, more than any other manufacturer. Models such as the Crosstrek, Forester, Outback, Legacy, and Impreza were among the vehicles recognized for combining strong safety performance with the practicality that many families look for when shopping for a first car.The list isn't based solely on crash-test performance. IIHS and Consumer Reports also evaluate factors such as emergency handling, braking performance, reliability, ease of operation, and overall safety technology. Vehicles must meet strict requirements to earn a recommendation, making the list one of the most comprehensive resources available for families shopping for a teen driver.AdvertisementAdvertisementAccording to IIHS data, teenagers remain among the most at-risk groups on American roads due to their lack of driving experience. While no vehicle can eliminate every danger, experts agree that modern safety systems and strong crash protection can help reduce the severity of accidents and improve outcomes when collisions occur.Subaru's strong showing is hardly a surprise. The brand has built a reputation around safety over the years, with many of its vehicles regularly earning top marks in crash tests. Features such as standard all-wheel drive on many models and the company's EyeSight driver-assistance technology have helped make Subaru a favorite among safety-conscious buyers.For parents preparing a teenager's first vehicle, safety extends beyond the car itself. Experts often recommend keeping emergency essentials on board, including a flashlight, first-aid supplies, an air compressor for low tire pressure situations, and a portable battery capable of jump-starting the vehicle if needed. Combined with a well-rated vehicle, these simple items can provide additional peace of mind during everyday driving.Perhaps the most encouraging aspect of the IIHS and Consumer Reports recommendations is that safety doesn't necessarily require a luxury-car budget. The list includes both affordable used vehicles and newer models, helping parents find suitable options without overspending.As the summer driving season begins and many teenagers prepare for road trips, summer jobs, and college visits, the latest rankings offer a timely reminder that choosing the right first vehicle is about much more than style or performance. For many families, peace of mind may be the most valuable feature of all—and Subaru appears to be delivering plenty of it.This story was originally published by Men's Journal on Jun 8, 2026, where it first appeared in the Gear section. Add Men's Journal as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
