Industry Minister Mélanie Joly is in a world of hurt. On the one hand, Stellantis looks to have formalized its retreat from building cars in Brampton, selling its assembly plant to Roshel, a manufacturer of armoured vehicles. At least, so say numerous news reports. On the other, as Motor Mouth explained earlier this week, the Minister of Industry’s long-promised lawsuit to recuperate the monies the federal government sent Stellantis’ way years ago is unlikely to recoup more than a fraction of the $222 million already spent. Her last five days have seen her on a hot seat no Liberal has experienced since Justin Trudeau retired. Her way out of this quagmire, set to be delivered to Stellantis management today, is to now offer the company an “aggressive package,” a last-ditch effort to compel the carmaker to reverse course and keep Brampton going as a working auto-assembly facility. On this front, she is even more constrained. As Motor Mouth also explained, depending on the exact final tariff rate Canada ends up negotiating with the U.S. — from the high of 50% that Trump has promised for January 1; to the ‘effective’ 7.5% that was the last offer proffered — producing the Jeep Compasses previously planned for Brampton would cost between $300 million and $1 billion in U.S.-imposed tariffs annually, a massive deterrent to continued production in Brampton. The Minister’s hands are also tightly bound over what she can offer Stellantis to reverse its decision and maintain ownership of — and eventually, production at — the Brampton facility. Considering that she is still trying to recoup the monies her department already gifted to retooling Stellantis’ production facilities, she assuredly can’t turn around and offer the company even more grants. Throwing good money after bad would be, if CTV’s rigorous grilling of Joly last Sunday is any indication, political suicide. So, what is a desperate Minister of Industry to do to save both the Brampton plant and her good name? Well, as fine a needle as the Minister will need to thread to get out of this mess, there might be a path to redemption. Here’s Motor Mouth’s take on a plan that might allow Ms. Joly to save face — i.e. keep Brampton open — without giving Stellantis more money. The ins and outs of tariff remissions As I said, giving Stellantis more money would seem to be a big no-no. On the other hand, saving them enough to make it worthwhile keeping Brampton open would probably keep the mainstream media’s attack dogs on a leash. Here’s how it might work. Canada, as I think pretty much everyone reading this column knows by now, charges a tariff on any U.S.-built passenger vehicle imported into Canada. To encourage the five automakers — General Motors, Ford, Toyota, Honda, and, yes, Stellantis — currently producing vehicles in Canada to stay loyal, the Canadian government has waived those duties. In other words, if Nissan or Hyundai tries to sell a U.S.-built car here, it would be subject to sales-killing surtaxes; if GM or Toyota did the same, those tariffs would be refunded. That said, Stellantis so pissed off the government when it first announced that it was moving Jeep Compass production to Belvidere, Illinois that Joly et al cut its tariff remissions in half, which means it should be paying duties on half the cars it brings in from the United States. That’s a boatload of money. A big boatload of money. And while it’s ultimately impossible to know exactly how much moolah that might be — it depends on what percentage of Stellantis’ Canadian sales come from the U.S. as opposed to Canada, Mexico, or other sources, as well as how much each car is worth — Motor Mouth will nonetheless take a stab at it. Our best reckoning is that about 50,000 of Stellantis’ 115,000 (or so) sales last year came from American assembly plants. It may actually be higher, but we’ll err on the conservative side. We’ll be equally circumspect with each imported car’s “landed cost,” which we’ll put at CAD$45,000. Do the numbers — 50,000 units coming in from the U.S. times $45,000 times 20% (a rough estimation of their effective tariff rate based on Canadian and Mexican content) times 0.5 (the half that Stellantis must now pay) and you come up with CAD$225 million per annum. Give or take $10 million or two, that’s Motor Mouth’s estimate of how much Stellantis’ Canadian arm has been paying in tariffs because it moved Compass production to the States. More importantly, that’s how much Stellantis will continue to pay each year for as long as the federal government applies counter-tariffs to American-built cars without lifting the company’s remission reductions. The flip side of the coin Stellantis, meanwhile, is also paying all those unemployed Brampton autoworkers. It’s called the Supplemental Unemployment Benefit and, according to Unifor, it requires that an automaker “top up” their pay over and above Employment Insurance such that, even when furloughed, they make 70% of their weekly pay. Currently, according to Canada.ca, EI tops out somewhere $700 a week, and a rough estimate — Unifor would not supply exact figures —of their weekly wage is about $2,000. Do some more math — $1,400 (70% of $2,000) minus $700 (that’s me assuming every autoworker gets maximum EI) — and you come up with an annual payout of $35,000 per year per worker. Assuming that said SUB benefit is paid to 1,800 Brampton Assembly workers (a few have decamped to Stellantis’ plant in Windsor to build Pacificas, Caravans, and Chargers) and you have a yearly cost of about CAD$60 million. If — when? — their EI benefits run out, those SUB benefits could balloon to $120 million, but the government would probably step in and extends workers’ employment insurance benefits. The deal that could be made If Ms. Joly wants to offer Stellantis a carrot without creating yet another media firestorm, she could offer to reinstate the company’s full tariff remissions in return for the company rescinding the plant’s sale to Roshel (which, by the way, may be the most difficult part of this whole plan). Oh, Stellantis wouldn’t have to re-open Brampton Assembly any time soon — with 50% tariffs looming and a finalized deal nowhere on the horizon, that might be an ask too far — as long as it maintains the promise of someday re-opening, and of continuing to pay its furloughed workers. In fact, this is a deal the Liberals understand well. As Motor Mouth has reminded everyone numerous times, Ford’s sole Canadian plant, in Oakville, remained idle all the way from May 2024 to October 2026, and yet the company still retained its full tariff remission. Such an arrangement could work out for everyone involved. For one thing, Stellantis saves a whole bunch of money, the elimination of tariff payments making up for any monies paid to furloughed workers. The Minister of Industry, meanwhile, saves face by getting that promise of a plant re-opening. Most importantly, she can go back on prime-time TV and claim that she did not offer Stellantis any new money, which is probably her most important consideration in this whole kerfuffle. Speaking of which— The leftover subsidy money still on the table Much has been made of the CAD$222 million of government money Stellantis Canada has already spent on retooling Windsor and Brampton ($198 million in Windsor, and just $24 million in Brampton, says the company). On the other hand, everyone seems to have forgotten that the total offered was CAD$529 million, leaving, if my calculator still works, some CAD$307 million left unspent. Now, no doubt these monies are not currently being offered, but were I Stellantis, I’d insist that, if I were to keep the plant open — and there was some off-chance that it might actually produce cars again — that those leftover 300 million loonies would be made available should further retooling be required in Brampton. Again, Ms. Joly could claim that she did not offer the company quote-unquote “more new money,” and I suspect the whole subterfuge would be old news by the time this whole mess came to an end.