Way bigger than before Looks good inside and out Solid ride and handling Too much touchscreen Powertrain lacks refinement Now just another SUV The weight of expectations can be a huge burden on any established vehicle that's received a lot of love in the past, especially one that's been as romanticized as much as the Mazda CX-5. When it burst onto the scene more than a decade ago, we fell head over wheels for the way it made us feel. The plucky SUV had charm for days—you could drive the front wheels off it, it looked dynamite, and it was packaged well and priced right. As a result, perhaps we expected too much from the new 2026 Mazda CX-5. Times have changed, and today's buyers presumably want more of what the latest version of Mazda's compact SUV delivers, namely a huge amount of space, safety, technology, and overall value. Renz Dimaandal - MotorTrend Its extra room is something our judges took note of, lauding the CX-5 for its massive back seat and 90-degree-opening doors that aid access to said back seat. The first impressions of the cabin were mostly good, with the materials choices, general seating, and overall packaging presenting well. Some of our SUV of the Year judges even got luxurious vibes. But then there's the CX-5's show-stopping centerpiece, its 15.6-inch center landscape touchscreen that serves at the vehicle's command center. It drew fire and ire from judges, who dinged it for being slow to react and having to dive too deep for accessing critical functions. "I appreciate the resolution and the graphics and the Google integration," features editor Scott Evans said, "but there are a lot of weird and bad choices in this screen." Several other judges were also aghast that there were no climate control buttons or a volume knob, a debate that continues to rage as voice controls and AI assistants begin their ascent. Renz Dimaandal - MotorTrend When we put the CX-5's rubber to the road, judges waxed nostalgic about its past glory as an SUV made for people who like driving (insert tired "zoom, zoom" reference here), a reputation its present incarnation has trouble matching. There were some high points, namely that it still can handle well when pushed, with most judges calling out a well-sorted chassis, strong, progressive brakes, and a heavy, connected steering feel, though some of them thought the steering's heft may become burdensome in daily operation. The biggest issue we had was with its 2.5-liter naturally aspirated four-cylinder engine with 187 horsepower mated to a six-speed automatic, which is a carryover from the prior model. "Aging" was a word that came to judges' minds, as was "underpowered," given how much more CX-5 heft the same powertrain now has to lug around. Technical director Frank Markus was blunt: "The engine seems increasingly out of date, and the six-speed is something to recommend against." Oh, and it's not very efficient, either. The good news is there is a hybrid model coming but not until sometime next year. Renz Dimaandal - MotorTrend Despite the downsides, there are other pluses to the CX-5. It's super safe, earning a 2026 Top Safety Pick+ from the IIHS, it's still one of the most attractive models in its class, and at $41,180 as equipped, it offers solid value. But despite its upsides, Mazda wasn't quite able to raise the bar high enough for the judges to elevate the CX-5 into our SUV of the Year finalist round. This review was conducted as part of our 2027 SUV of the Year (SUVOTY) testing, where each vehicle is evaluated on our six key criteria: efficiency, design, safety, engineering excellence, value, and performance of intended function. Eligible vehicles must be all-new or significantly revised.