Imagine, if you will (Twilight Zone music optional), a row of upscale sport sedans from Toyota's luxury brand, all parked in a line. One of those cars looks like the base model for its line, but it is not. It has a more-powerful optional engine. An engine that produces over 300 horsepower. Later on, the same automaker will produce a more-expensive pure sport-sedan version of this car. It will have V8 power, look cool, and cost a lot more. Perhaps, though, the sleeper version of this car can deliver most of the performance, be more inconspicuous, and work better as a daily driver. The Lexus IS F: The Legendary V8 Alternative If the basic Lexus IS was too tame for you—or too much a sleeper—Lexus had a V8-powered answer. Called the IS F, it arrived for the 2008 model year. With a 5.0-liter V8 that made 416 horsepower and 371 lb-ft of torque, the IS F turned a somewhat sporty small car into a serious performance sedan. It was so fast that it even outran the official 0-60 time. Lexus listed it at 4.6 seconds, but the car magazine, but period testingmeasured it at 4.3 seconds. Only 5,100 of these cars were built between 2008 and 2014, so between that rarity and the car's performance, they are quite desirable. It's the fastest Lexus IS of its generation on paper, it's more exciting, and now it's rarer. But being the fastest IS doesn't necessarily make the IS F the best one to live with. Wait, what? The IS350: More Than an Ordinary Luxury Sedan The mystery car, of course, is the 2007 Lexus IS 350. The 350 looked like the IS 250 but offered something the 250 didn't have—a 3.5-liter V6 making 306 horsepower and 277 lb-ft of torque. Some outlets list it as 300 hp, but that appears to be short by six ponies. This gave it a 0-60 mph time of between 5.4 and 5.6 seconds. Because the 350 looked so much like the 250 — the cars were nearly indistinguishable from one another — the 350 falls into the category of sleeper car. That's because it might look like a four-cylinder compact sedan for commuters, but it has a lot more power than you'd think just by looking at it. The V6, dubbed the 2GR-FSE by Lexus, has a reputation for reliability and durability, and it became a mainstay in other Lexus vehicles such as the GS and RC. To be clear, the 350 isn't a perfect performer. Its handling left a lot to be desired. Still, it is respectable. Lexus ended up with a car that's fun enough to drive that it's never boring, yet it never requires the compromises and sacrifices that many true sports sedans do. Compromises that the Lexus IS F required. The Hidden Cost of Being the Performance King With apologies to a 1990s rap hit, more power can lead to more problems. In this case, the IS F's notorious stiff suspension, while a wonderful feature for performance, made the car harder to live with. Power is wonderful, but a stiff ride can be a tough tradeoff when going to get groceries or cruising to dinner. To its credit, Lexus addressed this for the 2010 and later model years. Higher maintenance costs also play a part in the difference between the two cars. And, of course, the IS F's styling made its mission clear. If you want a sleeper car, if you want to avoid standing out, then you don't buy a car whose styling gives it away as a top performer. All that said, anyone who wants the IS F's performance can surely live with those tradeoffs. But someone looking for a blend-in daily driver would be better suited to the less-ostentatious IS 350. The Value Argument: Performance Without the Premium Price of entry matters, too. You can get into a 2010's IS 350 for under $15,000 while an IS F costs north of $20,000 on the used-car market. That premium price pays for performance, but as noted above, only about 5,100 IS Fs were sold. It's much easier to find an IS 350, since they were produced in much greater numbers. That obviously lowers the price. Money saved by not buying an IS F can be used for maintenance and repair on an IS 350. It can also be used for modifications and customization. The Verdict: The Better Lexus Is the One That Blends In Not everyone wants a sleeper car—some folks will want the IS F's higher performance and more-extreme styling. The tradeoffs won't bother them, and we do know that V8 power can atone for many sins. But the slower, quieter, and more-sedate-looking IS 350 is still quite the performer with that 5.4-5.6 second 0-60 time, and it will be an easier—and cheaper—car for daily driving. Road trips and urban commutes will be easier. The IS F might win the stoplight race, but the IS 350 wins the art of being underestimated. Sources: KBB, Fastest Laps, Lexus