Well, that didn’t work out well, now did it? One minute, the Prime Minister and the Minister of Innovation, Science, and Economic Development are unabashedly tarring Stellantis with the same brush as Stelco CEO Lourenco Goncalves — possibly the least PR-savvy corporate chief executive officer in Canadian history — and the next, they’re promising the automaker even more untold millions if it will just do as it’s told. “Doing as it’s told,” in case you missed it, means Stellantis shutting up. Or, more accurately, that it stop spreading a narrative that this isn’t the clear-cut story of corporate malfeasance the Liberals had been peddling lo these many long months. I mean, if Industry Minister Melanie Joly, after almost a year of dithering on legal action, decides to finally file a suit against the automaker, would I be the only skeptic wondering if she’s doing so now solely because it would offer her the cloak of silence she so desperately needs to fend off a media that smells blood in the water? Let’s be real: if you don’t think the “aggressive package” Stellantis is suddenly being offered is hush money, then you really don’t understand Liberal politics at all. So, what’s the real story? As always, Motor Mouth will take a stab at figuring out how we got here, what the legal beagles are really saying, and, most importantly — because this is all taxpayer-funded — how much money is involved. A quick recap of the Stellantis situation As we’ve all read, several years back, the federal government offered Stellantis CAD$529 million to retool its Windsor and Brampton assembly plants for new products. Two-hundred-and-twenty-two of those millions have already been spent: CAD$198 million went to the Windsor, Ontario facility, near the U.S. border; and just CAD$24 million was spent in Brampton, north of Toronto. Said retooling in Windsor has been successful, with the company adding a third shift a year ago to produce more Chargers, Caravans and Pacificas. Brampton, on the other hand, has been shuttered, and the all-new electric Jeep Compass it was supposed to pump out has been mothballed, with gas Compass production moved to Illinois to boot. Instead, Stellantis confirmed last week, the entire facility is being sold to Brampton-headquartered Roshel, which manufactures armoured vehicles. This, as Ms. Joly frequently reminds us, in an “outrage,” and is in breach of the agreement the automaker signed with the government. Stellantis, meanwhile, has offered to pay back that CAD$24 million specifically directed to Brampton retooling. Where legal beagles fear to tread The big question, then, is whether Stellantis has in fact failed to meet its obligations. And, for all of those reading — especially those Toronto Star readers slumming it here in search of their daily dose of outrage — we’re talking about their legal commitments, not moral. It is one thing to complain about someone’s lack of fiscal courage; it’s quite another to claim someone has breached a contract. One further caveat: I’m not a lawyer, so be forewarned that the following is but one layman’s opinion. The first thing we should note is that, like all such contracts, the Strategic Innovation Fund’s contract has a “force majeure” clause protecting Stellantis from events beyond its control: “The recipient will not be in default by reason only of any failure in the performance of the project in accordance with Schedule 1 – Statement of Work if such failure arises without the fault or negligence of the recipient and is caused by any event of force majeure.” As I mentioned last week, the imposition of tariffs on cars shipped from Ontario to the United States clearly fits that bill. Ditto the complete collapse of the electric-vehicle market in North America, caused jointly by Donald Trump’s rollback of EV incentives and the Liberals’ repeal of their own ZEV mandate. I suspect the lawyers representing the Ministry of Industry would counter that the Jeep Compass being a morceau de merde that nobody wants — have you noticed that Stellantis doesn’t seem to be in any hurry to produce the woebegone little Jeep in Belvidere, Illinois either? — doesn’t fit the definition of the “fault or negligence” exclusions to force majeure. In simpler terms, I figure they’ll argue that just ’cause people don’t want to buy the car you were going to assemble in Brampton doesn’t let you off your obligation to produce something they will want to buy. That said, an amendment written into a later edition of the contract may offer Stellantis a way out of that predicament as well. In redefining what is considered as a legitimate cause of default, the revision states Stellantis could be considered at fault if it is “unable to produce substantial evidence that it has promptly taken all reasonable commercial efforts to secure alternative mandates for the Brampton Assembly Plant.” Now, one could argue — as I suspect whomever is going to represent Stellantis in a courtroom will — that the company does have at least some evidence of that. You’ll remember that some time ago, an idea was floated to use the Brampton Assembly Plant for the complete-knock-down-kit (CKD) manufacturing of EVs engineered by Leapmotor, Stellantis’ Chinese partner. Minister Joly vehemently rejected the proposal because CKD production — cars would have been sent from China in ‘kit’ form, and the Brampton facility would have only been responsible for final assembly — meant that the plant would not have employed the 2,000-plus workers on furlough. There are also reports — mainly from CTV — that Stellantis is still considering the CKD idea, and could even lease a portion of its former plant from Roshel to do so. Stellantis’ lawyers — and maybe this is me pretending to be a legal beagle — will no doubt use this as proof the company has made that “reasonable commercial effort,” especially in the face of the 50% tariffs that Trump will impose on January 1. Hell, maybe they’re the ones floating the rumour that CKD production in Brampton is still a possibility. The calculation that emerges when you count the money With the rapture of the U.S. mid-terms yet to fade, it might be easy to forget that barely six weeks from now, the United States will impose a 50% tariff on any car shipped from Canada, a heck of a disincentive for any automaker looking to re-open a plant, especially one which, like Stellantis, just took a CAD$35-billion write-down. Just for context as to the havoc those January 1 levies might wreak: assuming Canada were to ship one million vehicles to the U.S. next year, with an average landed cost of CAD$40,000 each and 50% American content, our industry’s total tariff bill would be approximately CAD$10 billion, a number I know automakers can’t afford, and the government almost assuredly won’t subsidize. More specific to Stellantis, using the same numbers (but supposing 100,000 of those supposedly unpopular Compasses were sent across the border), the company would be on the hook for CAD$1 billion per annum, a number that vastly outweighs the CAD$222 million Ms. Joly wants back, let alone the $24 million that Stellantis has offered to pay back. Even if we go back to the last U.S.-Canada trade deal on the table — a 15% gross tariff reduced to 7.5% for American content — the amount that Stellantis would owe annually would be CAD$300 million. What I’m trying to say — and the reason, I suspect, that Joly and Carney are coming back with that supposedly more “aggressive” package — is that it would be cheaper for Stellantis to just pay all the money back than pay the tariffs liable. And, if a court were to side with Stellantis’ position that it only has to reimburse the CAD$24 million that it actually spent in renovating Brampton, that’d be lunch money compared to paying tariffs for even one year. Hate on automakers all you want, but unless Canada can negotiate a better deal with the U.S. — and, again, six weeks out, there’s no resolution in sight — all automakers will be facing equally difficult decisions. Author’s note: In a recent Globe and Mail article, Brian Kingston, president and CEO of the Canadian Vehicle Manufacturers’ Association, was quoted saying “We need relief, and we need relief quickly,” a request for immediacy that author Mark Rendell attributes to the fact that Ford and General Motors’ plants in Canada build trucks tht produce “higher per-vehicle profit margins than the compact cars or small SUVs produced by Honda and Toyota in Canada.” The implication, one assumes, is that automakers in Canada feel they could weather the tariffs the Americans offered in the last round of negotiations. If that be true, then maybe Stellantis — which was supposed to produce the not-quite-as-profitable compact Jeep SUVs in Brampton, and which builds sedans and vans in Windsor — should perhaps align itself more with the Japanese automakers that are imploring the government to aggressively reduce the effective tariff rate crossing the border, even if it takes more time.