German Car of the Year 2027: The Five Winners and What They Reveal About EVs Angus MacKenzie on how the results reveal where automakers may have gotten the EV future right—and wrong. It was quite a moment to stand with 15,000 people outside the Mercedes-Benz Museum in Stuttgart, Germany, and watch Mercedes-Benz chairman and CEO Ola Källenius announce to the crowd that the Mercedes-Benz S-Class was our 2027 Car of the Year. It was the first time in history our COTY winner had been revealed at a venue outside the United States. And the announcement was made just before three S-Class sedans drove on stage to officially complete a nine-month, 40,000-mile journey around the world to celebrate the 140th anniversary of the debut of the Benz Patentwagen, the rickety single-cylinder three-wheeler built by Karl Benz that Mercedes touts as the world’s first car. Car of the Year has been a big part of my career as an automotive journalist. MotorTrend invented COTY, of course, our first award going to the 1949 Cadillac. But Australia’s Wheels Magazine cottoned on to the idea in the early 1960s, awarding its first COTY in 1963 to the Renault R8, the roomy little rear-engine French sedan that boasted full independent suspension, a four-speed manual transmission, and four-wheel disc brakes, a big deal back then. I became a Wheels COTY judge in 1990, joining a panel of peers and experts that unanimously voted Mazda’s delightful little MX-5 Miata that year’s Wheels Car of the Year. Later, when I was editor-in-chief of Wheels, I led the development of the testing, evaluation, and voting processes that I would eventually bring to MotorTrend’s Car, Truck, and SUV of the Year programs in 2004, which are still used to this day. When I was asked to become a juror on this year’s German Car of the Year, I was intrigued. Their process would be different than MotorTrend’s, of course, though I would judge the contenders against the same criteria I have always used—engineering excellence, advancement in design, efficiency, safety, value (against each vehicle’s competitive set), and, most important, performance of intended function. But I wanted to see which vehicles caught the attention of the 47 jurors—mostly German automotive media—and why. All the rankings and voting data was analyzed by AItastic, an AI-driven media and business intelligence company based in Mainz, Germany. First shock: Out of the 109 vehicles eligible for this year’s GCOTY, the 20 highest-ranked by the jurors were EVs. Just four of the top 30 ranked vehicles were powered by an internal combustion engine. More than a few automakers might right now regret their expensive pivot to EVs in the context of their relatively poor sales over the past few years. But the GCOTY judging trend suggests history may see them as simply having been ahead of the curve rather than having taken a wrong turn. A deeper dive into the data revealed a couple of insights all product planners working on next-generation EVs should heed. Against the criteria, EVs topped the rankings in terms of significance, comfort, value, and safety, but ICE vehicles topped the design and fun-to-drive rankings. One fascinating side note: Hybrids, which in theory should offer the best of both worlds, topped none of the criteria. A bit like an all-season tire that’s OK in the dry and OK in the snow but not great in either, hybrids—particularly plug-in hybrids—were seen by the GCOTY jurors as jacks of all trades but masters of none. Chinese automakers are fast building market share in Europe. Chinese brands now outsell the Japanese in Europe, accounting for almost 15 percent of new vehicle sales across the EU and U.K. in September, and sales of Chinese vehicles are on track to reach 1.3 million units across the region during 2026. The AItastic analysis of the GCOTY jurors’ value rankings revealed why: They regarded the Chinese brands as delivering the best value, ahead of Japanese and then Korean brands. European brands came next. And American brands? Stone cold last. The GCOTY process whittled the 109 contenders down to five category winners: the Volkswagen ID.Polo (Budget), Kia PV5 (Compact), Mercedes-Benz GLC (Premium), Xpeng X9 (Luxury), and Hyundai Ioniq 6 N (Performance). It’s an eclectic list, and I’ll admit not all of them are cars I voted for. Let’s take a closer look at how I saw some of their strengths and weaknesses. Budget: Volkswagen ID.Polo The Volkswagen ID.Polo is significant because it reveals how VW Group intends to steer the design and execution of its EVs away from the soulless low-rent futurism of the original ID electric cars and toward vehicles that have presence and character. This little hatchback is all about upping the emotional quotient of the company’s EVs, to make them more approachable and desirable. Powered by VW’s new APP290 electric motor, the ID.Polo also shows how VW’s electric-powertrain vehicle architecture is evolving. The APP290 weighs 55 pounds less than the APP550 that powers the ID.4, thanks to a simpler, lower-cost water-cooling system. In Germany the base model starts at under the equivalent of $28,000, which buys you an ID.Polo with a 114-hp, 195-lb-ft version of the APP290. It is front-drive and takes 10.6 seconds to get to 62 mph, and it stores its energy in a heavy 37-kWh lithium iron phosphate battery that under EPA testing would likely deliver a range of just 175 miles. The top-shelf model gets 208 hp and 214 lb-ft, and it scoots to 62 mph in 7.1 seconds. It also gets a more energy-dense 52-kWh NMC battery that boosts the likely EPA-rated range to 240 miles. But this version of the ID.Polo costs $49,000 in Germany, 15 percent more than a base Tesla Model 3, which has more power and better range.