Autoblog and Yahoo may earn commission from links in this article.These brands uphold Japan's reputation for dependabilityJapanese engineering and reliability have always been closely tied. While Toyota generally has the best reputation, there have been plenty of other Japanese cars through the years that have racked up hundreds of thousands of miles and still somehow not fallen apart. Subaru is another company with a reputation for building quality, long-lasting vehicles, but how does this brand match up to Toyota? Here, we’ll take a look at the recent reliability record of these two brands, while also comparing some of their most popular models. We’ve consulted a variety of sources to get the most balanced view of dependability between these two brands.Consumer Reports: Toyota Takes Slim Lead2026 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid Woodland(C) 2026 Doug Berger | DBPicsIn the latest brand reliability rankings from Consumer Reports, the publication assessed data from around 380,000 vehicles from between the 2000 and 2025 model years. The researchers took into account 20 problem areas, including interior trim issues and software troubles to more expensive problems with the engine and transmission. The study also considers all powertrain types, from normal internal combustion models to fully electric vehicles. CR most reliable brands: Top 10Consumer ReportsToyota ended up with a predicted reliability score of 66 to lead all other makes. In second place was none other than Subaru, with a score of 63. The only other brand with a score of 60 or above was Lexus. These results show that Subaru and Toyota are incredibly closely matched in what is one of the largest studies for vehicle reliability.JD Power: Subaru Fights Back2025 Subaru ForesterSubaruThis year’s JD Power 2026 U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study (VDS) is a more recent look at brand-level reliability. Now in its 37th year, the 2026 study was based on the responses from 33,268 owners of 2023 model-year vehicles after three years of ownership. It addresses 184 problem areas across nine vehicle categories, including the powertrain, interior, seats, climate control, infotainment, features, and displays.AdvertisementAdvertisementUnlike in the Consumer Reports study, neither Toyota nor Subaru achieved a top 5 ranking, but both were still above the industry standard. Subaru ranked 6th, with 181 problems per 100 vehicles. Toyota was close behind in 8th spot, with its models seeing 185 problems per 100 vehicles. After Lexus, these were the highest-rated Japanese brands in the study.Once again, it’s remarkable to see how closely matched these two brands are, despite Toyota being the first one to be mentioned when reliability is discussed. These results indicate that Subarus are rather underrated.RepairPal: A Win For Toyota2026 Toyota Corolla HatchbackToyotaAccording to RepairPal ratings, the Toyota vs. Subaru reliability comparison swings in favor of the former. Subaru has a rating of 3.5 out of 5, placing it at 14th out of 32 brands. The publication rates Toyota 4 out of 5 for reliability and in eighth spot among all brands. Models from both brands see an average of 0.3 visits annually to a repair shop, but Subaru has significantly higher repair costs: $617 annually to Toyota’s $441.RepairPal’s reliability ranking covers 2010 to 2019 models and is based on the cost, frequency, and severity of unscheduled repairs and maintenance. So far, this is the first publication to demonstrate any significant gap between the two brands, with Toyota favored overall.Subaru Vs. Toyota Reliability: Most Popular Models Compared2026 Subaru Forester WildernessKristen BrownView the 2 images of this gallery on the original articleAdvertisementAdvertisementThe most popular models from each of these brands is the Toyota RAV4 and Subaru Forester, both compact crossovers. Although the RAV4 easily outsells the Forester, thousands of Americans buy both vehicles every year. But which one is more reliable?Consumer Reports recently put together a ranking of the top compact SUVs for 2026, and the Forester Hybrid led all models with an overall score of 88 out of 100, a brilliant ranking that’s consistent with Subaru’s generally excellent brand rankings. It was followed by the non-hybrid Forester (86/100) and the latest Toyota RAV4 Plug-in Hybrid (86/100). Yet again, we can see Toyota and Subaru challenging for the top spot in reliability rankings.These crossovers benefit from proven platforms and robust engine designs that have been refined through the years. While some rivals are more luxurious, the Forester and RAV4 are built to last, with sturdy materials that wear high miles well.Related: The Highest-Rated Compact SUVs For 2026 Come Down To Subaru Vs ToyotaWatch Out For Model-Specific Problems2022 Toyota Tundra V6ToyotaEven the most reliable brands have a few model- or powertrain-specific issues to watch out for. If you’re buying used, you can’t assume stellar reliability simply because a vehicle wears a Subaru or Toyota badge.AdvertisementAdvertisementCertain Subaru models with the 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine produced in the 2010s are notorious for high oil consumption, which can lead to major engine damage if you don’t keep a close eye on oil levels. We also recommend watching out for CVT issues on some older Subaru models like the 2019 Ascent, as the transmission can be prone to slipping, rough shifts, and loud noises.Toyota has had its fair share of engine troubles in recent years. The twin-turbo V6 used in the Tundra has been recalled more than once, with thousands of engines replaced due to machining debris that can cause knocking and rough running. These issues are potentially more serious than Subaru’s.Related: Kia vs Toyota Reliability: It’s Much Closer Than You ThinkToyota Dominates Longest-Lasting Cars List2023 Toyota SequoiaToyotaDo Subarus last as long as Toyotas? In a 2025 iSeeCars study of the vehicles that are most likely to last beyond 250,000 miles, Toyota dominated. It boasts 10 models in the top 25 and completes a sweep of the top 4, with the Sequoia, 4Runner, Highlander Hybrid, and Tundra leading the way. Subaru had no models in the top 25. While this doesn’t mean that Subarus are incapable of lasting this long, Toyotas do seem to be especially resilient at high miles. Furthermore, it wasn’t only tough pickups and body-on-frame SUVs that saw Toyota dominate the survey; the Prius, Avalon, and Camry also ranked in the top 25.Final Verdict: A Tie... Until You Reach Over 200,000 Miles2026 Subaru CrosstrekSubaruView the 2 images of this gallery on the original articleAdvertisementAdvertisementBased on the information available, choosing a Subaru or Toyota if you want the most reliable vehicle is far from a straightforward decision. Both brands consistently rank above the industry average for dependability; in some studies, Toyota leads, but Subaru was better in others. If you’re buying a lightly used vehicle and plan to keep it until around 150,000 miles, there’s very little to choose between these two brands and we’re calling it a tie. If, however, you’re buying a well-used vehicle with well over 200,000 miles, the data suggests Toyota has the edge. We’d highly recommend researching your specific model of choice to eliminate any common defects. Sticking to the models, engines, and transmissions that have no red flags is the best way to lower your risk.This story was originally published by Autoblog on May 27, 2026, where it first appeared in the Features section. Add Autoblog as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
+42 others
