A trade agreement that brings Canada and the United States back to the negotiating table may not be enough to satisfy Canadians increasingly frustrated by American tariffs. With economic uncertainty hanging over businesses, workers and households, public expectations for an acceptable deal appear to be shifting.

A new Nanos Research poll commissioned by CTV News finds that only 33.3 per cent of Canadians would support a trade agreement that maintains tariffs on Canadian goods, down from 41 per cent in August 2025.

The findings create another challenge for Prime Minister Mark Carney as his government tries to restore stability to Canada’s most important trading relationship. While securing an agreement could ease uncertainty, Canadians appear increasingly reluctant to accept one that leaves significant trade barriers in place.

Canadians Are Becoming Less Willing to Accept Tariffs in a Trade Deal

The latest Nanos Research findings suggest that Canadians are drawing a firmer line over what constitutes an acceptable agreement with the United States. Conducted between October 31 and November 2, 2026, the poll included 1,058 Canadian adults. Only 33.3 per cent expressed support for an agreement that would continue to impose tariffs on Canadian goods. The result indicates that simply reaching a negotiated settlement may not be enough to secure public approval, especially if major industries remain exposed to American import duties.

The distinction matters because tariffs have become more than a technical disagreement between governments. They represent uncertainty for manufacturers deciding where to invest, exporters trying to maintain customers and workers concerned about employment stability. Although the poll suggests that most Canadians are unwilling to endorse a tariff-inclusive arrangement, the 33.3 per cent figure measures support rather than providing a complete breakdown of opposition and undecided responses. It also does not establish which specific tariff concessions Canadians might ultimately accept.

Support Has Fallen 7.7 Percentage Points Since August 2025

The comparison with August 2025 highlights how Canadian attitudes toward a negotiated settlement have changed. At that time, a similar Nanos poll found that 41 per cent of Canadians were willing to accept a trade agreement that retained tariffs. The latest result represents a decline of 7.7 percentage points. That movement suggests a tougher public negotiating standard, even as governments face pressure to find a workable arrangement. However, polling alone cannot establish precisely why opinions have shifted or whether individual respondents changed their minds.

Other research provides useful context. A Nanos poll conducted from May 31 to June 2, 2026, for the Chicago Council on Global Affairs found that 69 per cent preferred Canadian leaders to resist trade concessions even if doing so worsened relations with Washington. Meanwhile, 52 per cent favoured maintaining the existing North American trade agreement rather than renegotiating less favourable terms. Together, these findings illustrate an important distinction: Canadians can support free trade while opposing concessions they consider damaging to their country’s economic interests.

CUSMA Remains in Force, but Tariffs Have Complicated North American Trade

Canada, the United States and Mexico continue to operate under the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement (CUSMA), which replaced NAFTA in July 2020. Although the United States declined to extend the agreement in its existing form during the July 1, 2026, joint review, the trade framework remains in force. That distinction is important because Washington’s decision did not immediately eliminate the agreement or its preferential trading rules. Canadian businesses can still benefit from tariff-free access where goods qualify, even as separate American trade measures create additional costs for affected industries.

The complication is that those protections do not prevent every tariff. American measures have targeted sectors including steel, aluminum and automotive products, while Canada introduced additional retaliatory duties in September 2026. Ottawa’s countermeasures covered approximately $27.6 billion in American imports, with rates ranging from 15 to 50 per cent depending on the products involved. A future bilateral settlement could therefore reduce some restrictions without eliminating every duty. For Canadian exporters, the details of those remaining measures may matter more than the announcement of an agreement itself.

Carney Faces Pressure to Secure a Deal Without Sacrificing Canadian Industries

Prime Minister Mark Carney has acknowledged progress in renewed discussions with U.S. President Donald Trump, but a final agreement remains elusive. Speaking in Manila on November 14, Carney disclosed that he had participated in a lengthy conversation with Trump and senior American officials before departing for his overseas trip. He indicated that a bilateral arrangement was possible but had not been finalized. The discussions marked a shift from August, when negotiations collapsed amid American demands that Ottawa considered unacceptable.

The political challenge is substantial. Carney must demonstrate that negotiations are producing meaningful improvements while avoiding an outcome that Canadians perceive as surrendering important economic protections. He has explicitly ruled out accepting an agreement that undermines Canada’s automotive industry, a position that reflects the sector’s importance to manufacturing communities. The latest Nanos findings suggest that negotiators may face public resistance even if they secure lower tariffs. A deal that provides stability but preserves significant duties could still be criticized for locking Canadian businesses into a disadvantageous arrangement.

Canada’s Auto Industry Shows Why Tariff Concessions Carry Serious Consequences

Few industries demonstrate the practical importance of the negotiations more clearly than automotive manufacturing. According to federal government figures, Canada produced more than 1.2 million vehicles in 2025, while automotive manufacturing employed approximately 121,600 people. More than 90 per cent of Canadian-built vehicles and about 60 per cent of Canadian-made auto parts are exported to the United States. Tariffs that discourage American buyers or increase production costs can therefore influence investment decisions throughout the Canadian automotive supply chain.

The uncertainty has become especially visible in Brampton, Ontario. Stellantis agreed in November to sell its idled assembly plant to Canadian defence manufacturer Roshel after shifting planned Jeep Compass production to Illinois. More than 2,000 workers had been laid off following the plant’s earlier shutdown. Although the company’s decisions cannot be attributed solely to tariffs, the dispute illustrates broader concerns about Canadian manufacturing competitiveness. For workers dependent on major assembly plants and their suppliers, the terms of a trade agreement can affect decisions that shape entire communities.

Canada’s Push Toward New Trading Partners Offers Hope, but Replacing the U.S. Won’t Be Easy

Canada’s efforts to diversify its trade relationships have accelerated as tensions with Washington continue. On November 14, Carney announced that negotiations had concluded for a Canada-Philippines free trade agreement and were substantially complete for a broader agreement with the Association of Southeast Asian Nations. The government hopes to sign both agreements in 2027. Ottawa estimates that the ASEAN arrangement, once implemented, could add nearly $2 billion to Canada’s economy and support approximately 14,000 jobs. These opportunities strengthen Canada’s long-term position, although the projected benefits have not yet materialized.

The challenge is the enormous scale of existing American trade. Statistics Canada reported that 71.7 per cent of Canadian merchandise exports went to the United States in 2025, compared with 75.9 per cent in 2024. That decline demonstrates measurable diversification, but it also highlights how difficult replacing American demand would be. For a Canadian manufacturer supplying an automotive assembly plant in Michigan, developing customers in Asia may require entirely different products, distribution arrangements and investments. New international partnerships can reduce dependence over time, but they cannot immediately replace deeply integrated North American supply chains.

Canadians Have Already Shown a Willingness to Accept Economic Pain to Resist U.S. Tariffs

Earlier Nanos findings indicate that Canadians’ resistance to tariff concessions is not limited to abstract expressions of dissatisfaction. Research conducted between August 30 and September 2, 2026, found that 85 per cent supported or somewhat supported Canada’s decision to reject a proposed American trade deal despite potential economic concerns. The same research found that 80 per cent supported or somewhat supported retaliatory tariffs on American imports. These results suggest that a substantial share of the public was prepared to support a confrontational negotiating strategy rather than accept conditions considered unfavourable.

That willingness extended to household finances, although concerns remained significant. Approximately 69 per cent said they were willing or somewhat willing to pay higher prices for everyday goods as part of Canada’s response to American tariffs. At the same time, 68 per cent expressed some degree of concern about the personal financial impact. These findings illustrate the tension facing policymakers: many Canadians support economic resistance while recognizing its potential costs. Importantly, willingness to accept higher prices in a poll does not establish how long that support would survive a prolonged period of financial hardship.

Prolonged Trade Uncertainty Could Put Jobs and Household Finances Under Pressure

The economic consequences of an extended dispute would reach well beyond companies directly paying tariffs. Statistics Canada research published in May 2026 found that production tied to exports destined for the United States accounted for 15.9 per cent of Canada’s GDP in 2024 and supported more than 2.5 million jobs. Another finding showed that 50.6 per cent of manufacturing businesses reported being negatively affected by American tariffs during the preceding year. These figures demonstrate how trade disruptions can spread through transportation companies, parts suppliers, contractors and communities connected to export-oriented industries.

Public willingness to continue resisting American demands also has limits. September polling by the Angus Reid Institute found that 60 per cent of Canadians were prepared to maintain a firm negotiating stance even if household costs increased by 20 per cent. However, support weakened as hypothetical consequences became more severe, including factory departures and personal job losses. A household with stable employment may view a prolonged negotiating dispute differently from a family relying on shifts at a vulnerable manufacturing plant. That difference matters when evaluating the political and economic risks of waiting for a stronger agreement.

New Polling Reveals a Mix of Optimism and Distrust Toward Washington

Recent research suggests that Canadians’ attitudes toward the United States are more complicated than outright opposition to negotiations. An Ipsos poll conducted November 10–12, 2026, for Global News found that 49 per cent felt more optimistic about securing a beneficial trade agreement following the American midterm elections. Nevertheless, 55 per cent continued to believe Canada could never trust the United States in quite the same way again. Only 39 per cent believed a trade agreement would actually be reached, demonstrating that renewed hope does not necessarily translate into confidence in the negotiating process.

The same Ipsos research found that 53 per cent favoured delaying a new trade agreement until after Trump leaves office. That preference creates an additional complication for Ottawa because postponing negotiations could preserve leverage while prolonging uncertainty for businesses. The Ipsos and Nanos findings measure different questions and should not be interpreted as identical assessments of public opinion. Taken together, however, they suggest that Canadians want both stronger economic protections and a more dependable relationship with Washington. Achieving those objectives simultaneously may prove difficult.

The Final Agreement Will Be Judged by the Tariffs It Actually Removes

The central question for Canadian negotiators is increasingly whether a future agreement delivers enough practical tariff relief to justify its compromises. September polling by the Angus Reid Institute found that 43 per cent of Canadians believed Ottawa should accept an automotive trade agreement only if American tariffs on Canadian vehicles were eliminated entirely. Another 31 per cent considered an agreement acceptable if those tariffs were reduced rather than removed. Those differences demonstrate that public expectations vary by the scale of the concessions being considered and the industries affected.

For Carney’s government, a politically defensible agreement would likely require clearly identifiable economic benefits rather than assurances of improved relations alone. Predictable market access, meaningful protection for major industries and enforceable trading rules could help establish its value. However, the latest Nanos result highlights the difficulty of persuading Canadians to accept an arrangement that preserves tariffs without sufficient compensating benefits. Negotiators must balance the economic advantages of reaching a settlement against the long-term consequences of accepting restrictions. Ultimately, the public’s judgment may depend less on whether Ottawa announces a trade deal and more on whether Canadian businesses and workers emerge with a stronger, more secure position.