A partly dismantled 1968 Shelby GT500 convertible is already a cool find. Make it a four-speed car in Candy Apple Red, and you've got something special. But when Dennis Collins and mechanic Gary started digging into this Florida project, they found a stowaway inside its 428 Police Interceptor V8, a broken pushrod that had apparently been riding along for decades. The kicker? This engine had already been through a Ford dealership for warranty repairs. How A Broken Pushrod Rode Inside This Shelby's 428 V8 For Decades Collins traveled to Florida to rescue the Shelby, which had spent more time on trailers than on the road. Its owner originally just wanted Gary to sort it into a decent driver. Brakes, fuel, nothing crazy. That plan didn't last. Gary took the 428 down to its short block, found the cylinder walls still in good shape, and had the heads rebuilt with new valves, springs, and guides. One of those heads turned out to be a factory warranty replacement. The original warranty paperwork explains why. It records a dealership visit for engine noise, with both heads pulled and the right head replaced to free up a valve. Then Gary pulled the intake manifold and lifted the valley pan. Sitting right there inside the engine was a broken pushrod. Gary reckons somebody over-revved the big-block, bent a pushrod, and damaged a valve. On a four-speed car, one missed shift from second to third would do it. The dealer swapped the head but apparently never lifted the valley pan to fish out the broken pushrod. That's his theory, and there's no way to prove exactly when it let go. Either way, a V8 that went through warranty work while still carrying a chunk of broken valvetrain is wild. And because the original engine never left the car, nobody stumbled on it until now. Why This Four-Speed GT500 Convertible Is So Rare The pushrod wasn't the only surprise. This particular GT500 is properly rare, even by Shelby standards. Shelby built 4,451 cars for 1968, and just 402 of them were regular GT500 convertibles, not counting the later GT500KR. Only 153 of those left the factory with a four-speed. Collins says this car is one of just nine built to its exact spec, though that figure hasn't been independently confirmed. Then there's the paperwork. A partial build sheet turned up wadded in the car, and nobody had paid it any attention. It confirms the Candy Apple Red paint, 6A interior code, black convertible top, and 3.50 rear axle ratio. That black top is a curveball, because Collins says most red cars with black interiors got a white one. It's also a no-stripe car with no air conditioning. It still needs plenty of bodywork, despite already wearing new floors. Collins eventually talked himself into another project and is bringing the GT500 back to life. At least the next time somebody opens up that 428, they won't find any forgotten pushrods waiting inside. Source: Dennis Collins YouTube