The Nissan Kicks was completely redesigned for the 2025 model year and is now in its second generation. It is a significant improvement over the old model, which used a weedy naturally aspirated 1.6-liter engine with 120 hp; the new NA 2.0-liter 4-cylinder produces a more useful 141 hp, but it’s by no means quick, with a drone-prone CVT automatic that needs quite a few revs before it gets going. It also doesn’t offer a powerful turbocharged alternative like the 250-hp Mazda CX-30. Nissan’s reliability in recent years has also been decidedly middle-of-the-road, and it took many years for the brand to fix its well-documented CVT problems. The redesigned new Kicks with its extroverted styling is now a strong effort, though, with many standard driver-assistance features and available AWD, but does it pull its weight in terms of reliability? We look at how the Kicks compare to its segment rivals and take results from various sources. Not all sources cover all models, so we throw the net wide to get a good data sample for predicting reliability. Nissan Kicks Reliability: RepairPal RepairPal’s reliability ratings are based on actual vehicle repairs, and it has been tracking vehicle reliability since 2017. This is how the Kicks shapes up against a few of its most obvious class rivals: Nissan Kicks Chevrolet Trax Honda HR-V Subaru Crosstrek Reliability Rating 4/5 4/5 5/5 4/5 Average Repair Costs per Year $500 $488 $301 $492 Repair Frequency per Year 0.31 0.18 0.1 0.13 Chance of a Major Repair 13% 12% 5% 7% The Kicks comes off as the worst among these four assembled competitors, with the Honda HR-V way out on its own for reliability and low repair costs in this class, according to RepairPal, and the Subaru Crosstrek not far behind. Maintenance Cost and Repair Projections: CarEdge CarEdge takes a short- and long-term view to assess maintenance costs up to 12 years into the future from new, and calculates the likelihood of an expensive repair in the first decade of ownership: Nissan Kicks Mazda CX-30 Chevrolet Trax Hyundai Kona Honda HR-V Subaru Crosstrek Total After 5 Years $2,426 $2,467 $2,777 $2,645 $2,347 $2,644 Total After 10 Years $7,791 $7,837 $9,000 $8,464 $7,479 $8,459 Chance of Major Repair in 10 Years 22.95% 22.65% 26.91% 24.76% 21.74% 24.76% The results for predicted Nissan Kicks reliability and problems at CarEdge are decent, with lower expected running costs than most of the listed rivals. It’s trading blows evenly with the Mazda CX-30, and beats the Chevy Trax quite comprehensively on both running costs and the likelihood of a major repair. However, the Honda HR-V again comfortably wins out, with CarEdge’s estimation of the Honda’s long-term prospects very much mirroring RepairPal’s. J.D. Power Where does Nissan fit in as a brand, when assessed according to reliability during the first three years of ownership? J.D. Power’s 2026 U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study assessed just that, and expresses the results in problems per 100 vehicles (PP100). There were quite dramatic changes from the 2025 results, which we show between brackets. Survey Ranking Out of 30 Brands Assessed Brand 2025 J.D. Power PP100 Survey winner Lexus 151 (140) #5 (6) Chevrolet 178 (169) #6 (16) Subaru 181 (212) #10 (18) Nissan 194 (215) #12 (20) Hyundai 198 (222) #16 (12) Honda 211 (201) Study Average 204 (202) #15 (3) Mazda 210 (161) Nissan improved dramatically from its 2025 score of 215, gaining a massive 21 points and scoring better than the study average this year, while Mazda’s results were dragged down by its big SUVs. These results bode well for its long-term prospects, though reliability can still be patchy and is dependent on the model you buy. How does the Kicks in particular score in its class? J.D. Power Quality & Reliability Rating 2027 Nissan Kicks 81/100 2026 Nissan Kicks 81/100 2025 Nissan Kicks 82/100 2025* Mazda CX-30 80/100 2026 Chevrolet Trax 83/100 2026 Hyundai Kona 89/100 2026 Honda HR-V 81/100 2026 Subaru Crosstrek 81/100 *2026 data were not available at the time of writing The 2026 and 2027 Kicks score solidly in the class, with its 81/100 Quality & Reliability rating at J.D. Power classified as “Great”, though the Honda HR-V (again) and the Chevy Trax fare even better. The Kicks was redesigned for MY2025, and the above 2027, 2026, and 2025 Nissan Kicks reliability results show that there was actually a small decline in reliability from the launch year. For context, this is how the last three model years of the first generation fared at J.D. Power; no 2021 Nissan Kicks reliability data were available. 2022 Nissan Kicks reliability: 88/100 2023 Nissan Kicks reliability: 82/100 2024 Nissan Kicks reliability: rating not available It seems that the previous-generation Kicks was generally more reliable than the new one, so we hope that Nissan will improve its results as the teething troubles are sorted out. Consumer Reports Consumer Reports predicts reliability over a far longer time scale, covering 380,000 vehicles over the last 25 years: Consumer Reports Predicted Reliability Nissan 57 Mazda 43 Chevrolet 42 Hyundai 48 Honda 59 Subaru 63 All old cars eventually break down and require expensive repairs to keep them going, so all the scores for the brands are generally quite a bit lower here, but still comparable to each other. Toyota leads the results with a score of 66, but among the Nissan rival brands listed here, only Subaru and Honda predict better results, and Nissan’s score is decent and significantly better than that of Hyundai, Mazda, and Chevrolet. Kelley Blue Book Consumer Ratings According to KBB’s Consumer Rating scale, the 2026 Nissan Kicks was rated 2.2/5 for quality and 2.5/5 for reliability, with an overall rating of 3/5: KBB Quality Rating Out of 5 KBB Reliability Rating Out of 5 KBB Overall Consumer Rating Out of 5 2026 Nissan Kicks 2.2 2.5 3.0 2026 Mazda CX-30 4.4 4.3 4.3 2026 Chevrolet Trax 4.4 4.6 4.6 2026 Hyundai Kona 3.6 3.5 3.6 2027 Honda HR-V 3.8 4.4 4.0 2026 Subaru Crosstrek 4.2 4.6 4.1 The 2026 Kicks fares rather poorly at KBB, and it’s the worst of all these assembled rivals. Final Thoughts As you can see from the divergent results from all the different organisations above, long-term reliability of a brand can depend on many factors, and each type of assessment has a different focus and bias, so the results must be seen as a whole and compared to each other. It’s even more difficult to find consistently agreeing data on the model level, but some patterns emerge, showing us the true state of affairs. One of these patterns is that neither Nissan as a brand nor the Kicks as a model wins any of the assessments above, but it’s mostly class average and rarely the worst, except for RepairPal’s estimations. It’s generally also not regarded as the best to drive or own daily in this class, where it, once again, scores rather middlingly. Nissan’s reliability has improved of late, and it’s making progress in its fight to survive. Though the Kicks is a solid effort in a hotly contested segment, it’s only average on reliability. Still, you can do worse, and it should remain dependable, as long as you stick to its maintenance schedule. The NA 4-pot should be very durable, but the CVT requires the right care and considered use to make it to high mileages.