The rising popularity of SUVs in the country has made compact SUVs a top choice among budget-conscious buyers. Consequently, this growing preference for compact SUVs has propelled the Tata Punch and the Nissan Magnite into the spotlight, garnering significant attention from car enthusiasts and potential buyers alike.
These compact SUVs combine style, performance, and practicality within an affordable price range, making them compelling choices for discerning consumers. Here is a detailed Tata Punch vs. Nissan Magnite comparison where we weigh the merits of the Tata Punch against the Nissan Magnite to help you make an informed decision.
Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite: Price and Variants
| Nissan Magnite | Tata Punch | |
| Starting Price (ex-showroom, Delhi) | ₹6.49 lakh | ₹5.99 lakh |
The Tata Punch is currently one of the most value-for-money cars in the country. It not only competes directly with rivals like the Hyundai Exter and the Maruti Ignis but also gives many entry-level compact SUVs a tough run for their money. The Nissan Magnite also boasts an affordable price tag, starting at ₹6.49 lakh, making it one of the cheapest compact SUVs in India.
Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite: Engine, Gearbox, and Performance
| Nissan Magnite | Tata Punch | |
| Engine | 1.0L NA Petrol, 1.0L Turbo Petrol | 1.2L Revotron Engine, 1.2L Revotron CNG Engine |
| Maximum Power | 71 bhp (NA Petrol)98.6 bhp (Turbo Petrol) | 86.5 bhp (Petrol)72.4 bhp (CNG) |
| Peak Torque | 96 Nm (NA Petrol)160 Nm (Turbo Petrol) | 115 Nm (1.2L P)103 Nm (1.2L CNG) |
| Transmission | 5-Speed Manual, CVT | 5-Speed Manual (Petrol and CNG)5-Speed AMT (Petrol) |
| Mileage | 18.75 km/l (NA MT) 20 km/l (Turbo MT)17.40 km/kg (Turbo CVT) | 20.09 km/l (P MT) 18.8 km/l (P AMT)26.99 km/kg (CNG) |
| Fuel Tank | 40L (Petrol) | 37L (Petrol)60L (CNG) |
The Nissan Magnite offers a choice of two petrol engines – a 1.0L naturally aspirated unit and a 1.0L turbocharged engine. The turbocharged engine is the more potent of the two, producing an impressive 98 bhp and 160 Nm of torque. It provides brisk acceleration and is well-suited for both city commutes and highway cruising. The Magnite boasts comfortable ride quality and handles urban traffic with ease.
On the other hand, the Tata Punch is powered by a 1.2L naturally aspirated petrol engine that delivers 86 bhp and 115 Nm of torque. While it may not be as powerful as the Magnite’s turbocharged engine, it packs adequate power and is suitable for city driving.
An optional 1.2L CNG engine is also available for the buyers, which comes with a 5-speed manual only. The Punch offers a slightly higher ground clearance, making it suitable for tackling rough roads and potholes. It delivers a comfortable and composed ride quality, ensuring a pleasant driving experience.
Check out our collection of Used Tata Punch Cars in India
Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite: Design And Dimensions
| Nissan Magnite | Tata Punch | |
| Length | 3,994 mm | 3,827 mm |
| Width | 1,758 mm | 1,742 mm |
| Height | 1,572 mm | 1,615 mm |
| Wheelbase | 2,500 mm | 2,445 mm |
| Boot Space | 336L | 366L |
| Seating Capacity | 5 | 5 |
The Nissan Magnite stands out with its bold and aggressive design language. Its sharp lines, sleek LED headlights, and prominent grille give it a distinctive look. The compact dimensions of the Magnite make it easy to manoeuvre in tight city spaces while still exuding a commanding road presence.
The Tata Punch, true to its name, has a robust and muscular appearance. It features a rugged front fascia with high-set headlamps, prominent wheel arches, and a sculpted bonnet. The design language of the Punch emphasises its SUV character and off-road capability.
Check out our collection of Used Nissan Magnite Cars in India
Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite: Interiors and Features
| Nissan Magnite | Tata Punch | |
| Headlamps | Projector LED Headlights | Projector Headlights |
| Keyless Entry And Push Button Start/Stop | Yes | Yes |
| Driving Modes | Yes | Yes – Eco, City |
| Infotainment System | Floating 20.32 cm Touchscreen Infotainment | 17.78 cm Harman Infotainment System |
| Apple CarPlay And Android Auto | Yes, Wireless | Yes |
| Audio System | 6-Speaker System | 6-Speaker Audio Setup |
| In-Built Navigation | Yes | Yes |
| Digital Instrument Console | 17.78 cm TFT Advanced Drive-Assist Display | 17.78 cm TFT |
| Follow Me Home Headlamps | Yes | No |
| Driver Seat Adjustment | 6-Way Manual | 6-Way Manual Adjustment |
| Seat Ventilation | No | No |
| Sunroof | No | Yes |
| Automatic Headlamps and Wipers | Yes | Yes |
| Surround View Camera | 360-Degree Camera | Rear-View Camera |
| Electronically Adjustable ORVMs | Adjustable And Foldable | Adjustable And Foldable |
| Auto-dimming IRVMs | No | No |
| Connected Car Tech | NissanConnect | iRA Connected Car Tech |
| Voice Recognition And Commands | Yes | Natural Voice Command Recognition |
| Air Purifier | No | No |
| Front Armrest | Yes | No |
| Cooled Storage | Yes | Yes |
| Foldable Rear Seat | 60:40 Split Folding | 60:40 Split Folding |
| Electronic Parking Brake | No | No |
| Ambient Lights | No | No |
| Automatic Climate Control | Yes | Yes |
| Wireless Charging Pad | Yes | No |
| Cruise Control | Yes | No |
The Nissan Magnite boasts a well-designed and ergonomically laid-out interior. Despite its compact size, the cabin feels spacious, thanks to clever space utilisation. The quality of materials used is decent for the segment, but fit and finish levels could have been better. The seats offer good comfort and support, making long journeys enjoyable.
On the other hand, the Tata Punch offers a modern and well-finished cabin. The build quality is robust, and the overall feel is sturdy. The Punch’s seats are comfortable and supportive, providing a comfortable ride experience even on rough roads. While the Punch may not have as many advanced features as the Magnite in its base variants, it compensates with its strong build quality and practicality.
Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite: Safety
| Nissan Magnite | Tata Punch | |
| Airbags | Dual Front Airbags | Dual-Front Airbags (Driver and Co-Driver) |
| Traction Control, Electronic Stability Program | Yes | Yes (AMT Only) |
| Hill Hold Control | Yes | Yes |
| ISOFIX Mount | Yes | Yes |
| Tyre Pressure Monitoring System | Yes | No |
| ADAS Safety Suite | No | No |
| Speed Sensing Auto Lock | Yes | Yes |
| Cornering Lamps | No | No |
| Safety Ratings | 4-Star GNCAP | 5-Star GNCAP |
With a GNCAP safety crash test rating of 5 stars, the Tata Punch is currently the safest car in its segment and is offered with a long list of safety features and equipment. The Nissan Magnite is not far behind, having scored an impressive four-star rating in the same tests.
Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite: Warranty, Reliability, and Resale
| Standard Warranty Coverage | |
| Nissan Magnite | 2 Years/ 50,000 Km Standard Warranty |
| Tata Punch | 3 Years/ 1,00,000 Km Standard Warranty, 3 Years/ 1,00,000 Km Roadside Assistance |
Both the Nissan Magnite and the Tata Punch are likely to offer similar long-term reliability; however, it is the Tata Punch that provides better warranty coverage and superior after-sales support. Additionally, the Punch offers a higher resale value compared to the Magnite.
Our Verdict
Both the Nissan Magnite and the Tata Punch have their unique strengths, making them appealing choices in the subcompact SUV segment.
If you prioritise a more feature-rich interior and a peppier engine, the Nissan Magnite might be the better option for you. Its modern features, spacious cabin, and turbocharged engine give it an edge in terms of urban practicality and driving pleasure.
On the other hand, if you value robust build quality, a comfortable ride experience, and a more rugged exterior, the Tata Punch is worth considering. It offers a dependable performance for daily commutes and the ability to handle rough terrains with ease.
FAQs
Q. Which one has better mileage, the Tata Punch or the Nissan Magnite?
The Tata Punch delivers better fuel economy compared to the Nissan Magnite and is also offered with a CNG powertrain option.
Q. Which car is cheaper, the Tata Punch or the Nissan Magnite?
The Tata Punch is cheaper than the Nissan Magnite and is priced at ₹5.99 lakh in the Indian market.
Recently Added Cars to Buy
2022 Mahindra XUV700
- AX 7 LUXURY D AWD AT 7 STR
- |
- Automatic
- 4,418 km
- 1st Owner
- Diesel
- DL-7C
2021 Jeep Compass
- SPORT 1.4 PETROL DCT
- |
- Automatic
- 37,129 km
- 2nd Owner
- Petrol
- DL-1C
2021 Tata Harrier
- XZA PLUS 2.0L
- |
- Automatic
- 32,973 km
- 1st Owner
- Diesel
- UP-32
2021 Tata Safari
- XZA+ KRYOTEC
- |
- Automatic
- 43,022 km
- 1st Owner
- Diesel
- DL-3C
2018 Volkswagen TIGUAN
- HIGHLINE A/T
- |
- Automatic
- 88,907 km
- 1st Owner
- Diesel
- DL-10
2018 Toyota Innova Crysta
- 2.4 VX 7 STR
- |
- Manual
- 71,914 km
- 1st Owner
- Diesel
- DL-14
2021 Tata Harrier
- XZA PLUS 2.0L
- |
- Automatic
- 88,980 km
- 1st Owner
- Diesel
- UP-14
2019 Jeep Compass
- 1.4 LONGITUDE (O) AT
- |
- Automatic
- 23,690 km
- 1st Owner
- Petrol
- DL-3C
- Recent
- Features
Tata Altroz vs Tata Tiago Comparison – Price, Features & Specifications
Published on: 18th September, 2023 IST
Maruti Swift Vs Maruti Swift Dzire Comparision – Price, Features, Safety & Performance
Published on: 15th September, 2023 IST
Skoda Slavia Vs Volkswagen Virtus Comparison – Price, Features & Specifications
Published on: 15th September, 2023 IST
Maruti S Presso vs Renault Kwid Comparison – Price, Features, Safety & Performance
Published on: 15th September, 2023 IST
Tata Altroz Vs Tata Punch Comparision – Price, Features, Specifications, Safety
Published on: 15th September, 2023 IST
5 Mistakes to Avoid When Buying A Pre-owned Car
Updated on: 15th September, 2023 IST
Tips to Become an Informed Car Shopper
Updated on: 15th September, 2023 IST
How to Spot a Flood-Damaged Car?
Updated on: 15th September, 2023 IST
High Security Number Plate(HSRP): All You Need to Know
Updated on: 14th September, 2023 IST
Used Car Vs Certified Pre-owned: Which One Should You Buy?
Updated on: 2nd September, 2023 IST
10 Benefits of Buying a Used Car
Updated on: 28th August, 2023 IST
Used Car Vs New Car: Which is Better to Purchase?
Updated on: 18th August, 2023 IST
All About Fancy Number Plate For Cars
Updated on: 4th August, 2023 IST
Most Popular Used Cars to Buy in India in 2023
Updated on: 25th July, 2023 IST
All You Need to Know About The Vehicle Scrappage Policy In India
Updated on: 13th December, 2022 IST
How To Take Care Of Your Car During The Monsoon
Updated on: 4th July, 2022 IST
Keyword: Tata Punch vs Nissan Magnite Comparision – Price, Features, Safety & Performance