When comparing compact sedans, the Mazda3 and Toyota Corolla come head to head as two of the best small cars in the segment. With each of the new sedans carrying a starting price hovering around the $21,000 price point, it will take more than budget considerations to choose one or the other. Let’s take a closer look at the pros and cons of each to decide which new car is right for you.

The pros of the Mazda3

mazda3 vs. toyota corolla: which compact sedan does consumer reports recommend?

2022 Mazda3 Carbon Edition | MAZDA NORTH AMERICAN OPERATIONS

From the first glance of the Mazda3, its stance and overall body sculpture convey the Mazda3’s sporty nature, especially compared to the Toyota Corolla’s functional styling. However, it’s not just for show. The Mazda3’s 2.5-liter engine and six-speed transmission work together to provide 0 to 60 mph acceleration in just over 7.5 seconds. The Mazda3 also outperformed the Corolla in Consumer Reports (CR) braking tests and is “more enjoyable to drive.”

Inside the Mazda3, you’ll find comfortable padded touchpoints, including its armrests and the steering wheel, along with what CR calls “high-quality trim, buttons, and knobs throughout.”

Consumer Reports reviewers also found the Mazda3’s low levels of interior noise added to its “premium” feel but noted that in lower trim levels, “neither the Mazda nor the Toyota has great seats.” However, the Mazda3 still edges out the Corolla slightly.

If you prefer a sedan with all-wheel drive (AWD), it’s available on the automatic-transmission-equipped Mazda3 but not on the Corolla.

Manufacturer warranties are similar for both cars, but Mazda has three years or 36,000 miles of roadside assistance compared to Toyota’s two years or unlimited miles. You’ll have to choose which one fits your driving needs better.

The pros of the Toyota Corolla

As is typical in most cases, the Toyota Corolla gives up the edge in sportiness with its 1.8-liter four-cylinder engine and continuously variable transmission (CVT) to gain the advantage in fuel economy by more than a few mpg in base form. Toyota offers the Corolla Hybrid for up to 53 EPA-estimated mpg if you want even better fuel economy. In comparison, there isn’t a hybrid option available for the Mazda3. Where the Mazda3 offers a firm ride and responsive handling worthy of track days, the Corolla exhibits competent handling of its own and maintains a “very good ride quality” that soaks up bumps on uneven pavement.

Inside the Corolla, its controls are well laid out and easy to use. Each selection provides positive feedback allowing easier adjustment with minimal distraction while driving. As a result, Corolla gets the nod in this category over the Mazda3’s sometimes difficult-to-decipher controls.

Where Mazda and Toyota offer differing solutions for roadside assistance, Toyota wins this round with two years or up to 25,000 miles of regularly scheduled maintenance, which Mazda does not provide.

The Toyota Corolla also outperformed the Mazda3 in CR’s annual surveys, where owners report their vehicle’s reliability. However, both groups of owners reported similar satisfaction with their cars.

Mazda3 and Toyota Corolla similarities

Both cars will benefit from additional options available at higher trim levels. Everything from improved seat comfort to advanced driver safety assistance, some of which aren’t available on base models at all, are standard or at least an option the higher you go.

Both vehicles suffer from low roof lines that limit entry access. Another consequence of the low roofline is that short windows and windshield pillars are too close, limiting visibility.

Consumer Reports narrows down the choices to the sport-minded or the budget conscious. The sport-minded driver will likely enjoy the “fun to drive” Mazda3. Still, they’ll need to pay extra to get the forward collision warning and automatic emergency braking standard on lower-trim Corollas. Corolla buyers will get a reliable, safe, and practical car with lower annual fuel costs, but it won’t be as much fun to drive, depending on how you measure fun.

Keyword: Mazda3 vs. Toyota Corolla: Which Compact Sedan Does Consumer Reports Recommend?

CAR'S NEWS RELATED

Mazda RX-30 R-EV Rotary, Abarth 500e, Pininfarina Battista Record: RAC #99

We also catch up on listener emails, comments, and we share what we're thankful for in the automotive realm.

View more: Mazda RX-30 R-EV Rotary, Abarth 500e, Pininfarina Battista Record: RAC #99

2023 Honda Pilot vs. 2023 Toyota Highlander: Classic Three-Row Midsize SUV Battle

2023 Honda Pilot vs. 2023 Toyota Highlander: Which SUV has more interior room? Which three-row midsize SUV offers a hybrid powertrain? Which of these SUVs offers removable middle-row seats? Which three-row midsize SUV is right for your family? The 2023 Honda Pilot is all-new, bringing in the fourth generation ...

View more: 2023 Honda Pilot vs. 2023 Toyota Highlander: Classic Three-Row Midsize SUV Battle

Mazda hints at new electric sports car and details huge EV investment

LONDON: Mazda has hinted at a new electric sports car as part of a new confirmation that it was investing US$10.6 billion (RM48bil) in its electrification plans. The Japanese carmaker has today revealed further information about its management plan to take Mazda up to 2030, as well as developing ...

View more: Mazda hints at new electric sports car and details huge EV investment

Toyota Tacoma Pros and Cons You Must Know Before Making Your Next Purchase

Toyota Tacoma advantages The Tacoma disadvantages Other key features of the Toyota Tacoma Critics don’t always agree with buyers on whether vehicles are worth buying, but the Toyota Tacoma has many of these reviewers split. If you’re interested in getting your hands on one of these trucks, do your ...

View more: Toyota Tacoma Pros and Cons You Must Know Before Making Your Next Purchase

Is 2023 Toyota Camry TRD a Good Sports Car Alternative?

2023 Toyota Camry TRD: Is it fast? Performance features in the sports car-like 2023 Camry TRD 2023 Camry TRD: Unique design features Roomy interior makes the Toyota Camry TRD a practical alternative to sports cars Many standard driving assistance features in the 2023 Camry TRD Toyota Camry TRD is ...

View more: Is 2023 Toyota Camry TRD a Good Sports Car Alternative?

Toyota announces unchanged driver line-up for 2023 WEC season

The Japanese manufacturer announced on Friday that Kamui Kobayashi, Mike Conway and Jose Maria Lopez will again race the #7 Toyota GR010 HYBIRD and that reigning champions Sebastien Buemi, Brendon Hartley and Ryo Hirakawa will stay together in the #8 Le Mans Hypercar. Lopez, who won the WEC title with ...

View more: Toyota announces unchanged driver line-up for 2023 WEC season

Toyota Vios dominates the Sepang 1,000km race with a historic 1-2 finish

It was a masterclass in domination for the humble Toyota Vios as it proved its mettle on the racetrack with a historic 1-2 finish at the Sepang 1,000KM endurance race and a total of three Toyotas in the top 5 overall positions. The 9-hour race concluded with Toyota Gazoo ...

View more: Toyota Vios dominates the Sepang 1,000km race with a historic 1-2 finish

Higher specs than Indonesia, 2023 Toyota Innova launched in India with HyCross name

Just weeks after its global debut in Indonesia, India has launched the all-new 2023 today. If you have watched enough Hindi movies or news clips from India, you would know that the Toyota Innova is viewed very differently over there. In India, the Innova is almost on par with ...

View more: Higher specs than Indonesia, 2023 Toyota Innova launched in India with HyCross name

Toyota Innova Hycross unveiled in India; bookings open

Toyota Innova Hycross Debuts In India – 21.1 Kmpl Mileage ARAI

Toyota Motor PH To Continue Assembling All-New Vios In The Philippines

Does the 2022 Honda Passport Even Compare With the 2022 Toyota 4Runner?

6 Toyota Models Dominate the Least Expensive Cars to Maintain

Toyota Hilux and Ford Ranger utes to go electric as pricing revealed for mass EV conversions

Mazda CX-3 2023 review: Akari LE petrol long-term | Part 1

Watch: Toyota Prius has just got good, but it's too late for NZ! Zooming with DRIVEN EP111

First Drive: 2023 Toyota GR Corolla

Toyota Sienna or Honda Odyssey: What’s the Most Reliable Minivan?

Which Toyota Agya trim holds its value better?

Look out Toyota Prado! Nissan says its toughened-up Pathfinder will lure customers from the top-selling large SUV, as well as Ford Everest and Isuzu MU-X

OTHER CAR NEWS

;
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network