Rarely does a decision come along that’s both surprising and unsurprising seemingly in equal measure.

Some will defend Mattia Binotto because of the progress Ferrari has made under him, because some of Ferrari’s shortcomings aren’t his fault and because he’s inevitably another victim of the political drama synonymous with this team.

On the other hand you could argue Ferrari had to make a change after 2022, a season that was a key chance to score a long awaited title but in which it all slipped away through poor tactics and a rate of development that didn’t match its opponents.

Here, our writers give their verdict on Binotto’s exit and the repercussions.

FERRARI HASN’T REALLY PROGRESSED

Ben Anderson

is binotto exit really what’s best for ferrari? – our verdict

It’s one thing for Ferrari to be competitive – that’s always a bare minimum expectation – but for Ferrari to have gone backwards as 2022 progressed, and be left with little to show for all the pain of 2020 and 2021, is simply not good enough.

The comments of Ferrari chairman John Elkann, issued ahead of the team’s home race at Monza, backing Binotto but also clearly saying the team was still deficient in many aspects, effectively served notice.

Red Bull started on the back foot and was there for the taking through the first half of 2022. Ferrari didn’t take advantage, and unlike Mercedes (and Red Bull) also couldn’t find a way to become more competitive as the season progressed.

Binotto bears ultimate responsibility for that failure. He did much that was good and no doubt changed Ferrari’s working culture for the better. But he didn’t properly fix the F1 team’s weaknesses, and it’s difficult to argue Ferrari is more effective as a title-challenging operation now than it was in 2017 and 2018.

Decision needs to be based on reason, not scapegoating

Edd Straw

is binotto exit really what’s best for ferrari? – our verdict

A change of leadership is always the most impactful way to tackle problems as far as the public perception is concerned. But what really matters is that any such switch is based in sound reasoning rather than scapegoating and blood-letting.

What must be avoided is the football team mentality whereby a manager is the lightning rod for all criticism and their removal a panacea. Ferrari certainly needs to sharpen up but the key question was what was Binotto’s role in the failure to do so?

As the team principal, he is by definition responsible. But what really matters is that the prevailing institutional weaknesses are tackled. Sometimes, a change of leadership can be seen as a means unto itself. But for Ferrari to have a chance of winning a championship any time soon, it must be a means to an end.

If Binotto alone truly was an obstacle to the necessary reforms, his departure is the right move. If not – and it’s more likely he would only have been part of the problem – it’s essential him stepping down is just part of the solution rather than its totality.

What matters now is Ferrari replaces him with the right long-term option to achieve genuine stability that will allow F1’s most famous team to stop underachieving.

Binotto was left isolated and weakened

Mark Hughes

is binotto exit really what’s best for ferrari? – our verdict

It’s not a surprise, but it’s disappointing all the same, that the non-racing senior management has fallen for a Groundhog Day move seemingly unaware of the pattern of the team’s own history.

Binotto needed to make changes but needed support in making them, not constantly expending energy in dealing with the political fall-out of every little in-the-field mishap.

He was progressively left in a position of isolation, paralysed from setting his own route to the goal as each power unit failure or strategy error carried an accumulated weight. Thereby increasing the probability of further failure.

The Ferrari team principal needs to have a protective force around them, as in the Jean Todt/Ross Brawn days but it’s structured in such a way that there is instead a weak wall of decaying strength.

It was never going to work

Gary Anderson

is binotto exit really what’s best for ferrari? – our verdict

I have said from the beginning that having one person filling two positions (team principal and technical director) is never going to work, especially at Ferrari.

If I had been offered that position, it would have been a resounding ‘no thanks’, so if he took it with open arms then he is suffering the consequences that he has brought on himself. If he was persuaded to take up that position, then it is whoever did the persuasion that is responsible for the mess Ferrari is in.

As far as performance is concerned, Ferrari in 2022 has been a revitalised team. Yes, it has made some strategy errors and suffered some reliability problems, all those are there to be seen first hand. So to me the biggest problem is that it hasn’t stood up and shouted about the problems and plans to solve them publicly.

If we can’t see reaction then the tifosi can’t see it either, and they are the ones that put the pressure on anyone that works at Ferrari.

Binotto has proven over the years that he is good at what he is good at and that is the technical side of F1. He has now suffered the consequences of bringing Ferrari to the front once again, but not quite reaping the ultimate reward.

Self-defeating culture continues

Scott Mitchell

is binotto exit really what’s best for ferrari? – our verdict

This undermines Ferrari’s bid to move away from a culture that was self-defeating. It doesn’t really matter whether Binotto has jumped or been pushed.

Either the John Elkann/Benedetto Vigna combination has decided that Binotto’s not the right person to lead the F1 team, or Binotto has decided ‘I cannot trust this organisation’.

Either way, it doesn’t reflect well on the company’s senior management. Because the downside to keeping Binotto for 2023 was not particularly great. But the upside, if he was the right person to lead the team, could have been huge as we would have seen signs of the necessary progress.

My best guess is that Elkann/Vigna didn’t want Binotto in charge and either nudged him out or Binotto cottoned on and walked anyway. This has felt like a possibility for a couple of years – basically since Louis Camilleri left at the end of 2020.

Camilleri, formerly Ferrari CEO, was a key backer of Binotto and the two developed a close working relationship after the late Sergio Marchionne identified Binotto as the leader Ferrari needed (even though the change didn’t happen until after Marchionne’s death).

This is what led to Binotto being made team principal in place of Maurizio Arrivabene at the start of 2019, as Camilleri’s backing empowered Binotto beyond Marchionne’s passing.

Camilleri and Binotto were the driving forces of the move to eliminate a culture of blame and fear at Ferrari. Now both are gone.

There needs to be a well vetted replacement already

Jack Benyon

is binotto exit really what’s best for ferrari? – our verdict

Whether Binotto has left of his own accord or been shoved out by Ferrari ‘gestione’, it’s clear Ferrari’s management isn’t happy with the way things are going in F1 at the moment.

That being said, it has to have drawn up a shortlist of potential Binotto successors or this is going to end up being a woeful situation.

While Ferrari hasn’t exactly reached its full potential under Binotto, there’s upside as well. Enough upside that it’s better to keep him in than now rush to bring in an ill-prepared successor to have to deal with the political intricacies of managing a Ferrari F1 team entails.

With Ferrari guilty of poor strategy and falling further behind Red Bull – and further into the crutches of an improving Mercedes – this feels like a crossroads for the team. The right decision might galvanise it and the wrong one might tear it apart.

2022 proved this is the right decision

Sam Smith

is binotto exit really what’s best for ferrari? – our verdict

Motorsport isn’t football when it comes to hirings and firings thank goodness, yet Binotto’s role at Ferrari ceasing has to be the least surprising news of the season. The overwhelming evidence after 2022, as good a shot at a title as Ferrari has had in years, is that this is 100% the correct decision.

The litany of errors and missed opportunities following in particular Charles Leclerc’s excellent start to the season was one thing. Binotto’s intransigence of being unable to see his and the team’s own failings seemingly at all was another thing altogether.

Whether Binotto was out of his depth in that role is probably a question that can only be answered in the near future when his successor will have a couple of seasons behind them to analyse. But I’d suggest that if a poll was conducted with the Tifosi it would be nothing less than a rout.

Even if he had the management and people skills to get a stay of execution it would seem generous. But there was a perceived dearth of these.

For now, the last few seasons will attest to mediocre success in relation to the resources and talent, both in and out of the cockpit, that Ferrari possesses. In the context of the Prancing Horses famine of title’s, now standing at close to 15 years and getting close to the 1983 to 1999 desert, much, much more is expected and demanded.

Keyword: Is Binotto exit really what’s best for Ferrari? – Our verdict

CAR'S NEWS RELATED

Ferrari 246S Dino & Lotus 15 Go Neck And Neck At The 2021 Goodwood Revival

A thrilling video of a Ferrari 246S Dino and Lotus 15 going neck and neck as they compete for the Sussex Trophy at the Goodwood Revival in 2021.

View more: Ferrari 246S Dino & Lotus 15 Go Neck And Neck At The 2021 Goodwood Revival

The Fall Of Rome: Ferrari Plummets After Elevator Breaks Down

Firefighters needed four hours to clear the area.

View more: The Fall Of Rome: Ferrari Plummets After Elevator Breaks Down

Christian Horner begins mind games with Ferrari’s Fred Vasseur, and digs at Mercedes and Williams over James Vowles move

Christian Horner has started the F1 team principal mind games by questioning aspects of James Vowles’ exit from Mercedes, and aiming a jab at Ferrari’s new boss. Former Renault, Sauber and Alfa Romeo boss Fred Vasseur has taken over at Maranello, replacing Mattia Binotto, while Vowles left his role ...

View more: Christian Horner begins mind games with Ferrari’s Fred Vasseur, and digs at Mercedes and Williams over James Vowles move

Botched Elevator Ride Destroys Ferrari Roma

How did they get the Ferrari Roma out of the elevator? Will the Ferrari Roma be totaled? How much power does a Roma have? A car dealership in Palm Beach County, Florida, experienced an unfortunate elevator accident involving a new Ferrari Roma. The dealership uses the elevator to hoist ...

View more: Botched Elevator Ride Destroys Ferrari Roma

David Beckham's Ferrari 360 Spider is now on sale for RM574k

The car was Beckham’s daily driver 20 years ago Just a few days after news broke that the late rally legend Collin McRae’s Subaru Impreza S5 P2 WRC is looking for a new owner, another interesting listing from the UK has made its way to automotive news portals around the ...

View more: David Beckham's Ferrari 360 Spider is now on sale for RM574k

Have You Tested it Virtually Yet? Ferrari Vision Gran Turismo

Maranello's first Gran Turismo concept car may offer a glimpse into the future.

View more: Have You Tested it Virtually Yet? Ferrari Vision Gran Turismo

Ferrari Set New Sales Record In 2022 By Delivering 13,221 Cars

Net profit also set a new record for the company.

View more: Ferrari Set New Sales Record In 2022 By Delivering 13,221 Cars

Ferrari Couldn't Be Stopped Last Year

Image: Ferrari Ferrari can do no wrong, Tesla’s suppliers are peeved at its price shenanigans and electric semis have a big problem. All that and more in this Thursday edition of The Morning Shift for February 2, 2023. 1st Gear: Never Bet Against the Horse It must be a ...

View more: Ferrari Couldn't Be Stopped Last Year

Ferrari sees "even stronger 2023" after beating forecasts in Q4

McLaren Artura Drive Review : Art of Speed [COTY2022]

Ferrari’s new F1 boss Frederic Vasseur twice tried (and failed) to sign Carlos Sainz 

Charles Leclerc doesn’t need No 1 status, he needs Ferrari to be decisive

New Ferrari F1 boss Fred Vasseur reveals ‘handover’ from Mattia Binotto and advice from Jean Todt

Ferrari F40

Haas F1 Has No Intentions of Cutting Ties With Ferrari

Was Charles Leclerc finger-wag the trigger for Mattia Binotto’s Ferrari F1 downfall? 

Montoya predicts Sainz could be a problem for Leclerc in 2023

Vasseur believes Ferrari has ‘everything needed to win’

1965 Ferrari 330GT

Vasseur not rushing to secure Leclerc beyond 2024

OTHER CAR NEWS

; Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự