Autoblog and Yahoo may earn commission from links in this article.First impressions aren't everythingThe Honda CR-V is the best-selling individual model in the U.S. so far this year. Its sales have increased concurrently with inventory challenges suffered by the Toyota RAV4 and Ford F-150, catapulting the Honda to the top of the sales charts in 2026. While we rate the CR-V highly, it's not the most satisfying new compact crossover to own. That's according to a new JD Power study, which places at least three rival SUVs ahead of Honda in the initial months of ownership, but the CR-V is still a smarter choice than most as these vehicles age. Here's a closer look at the results.Related: I Drove the 2026 Honda CR-V TrailSport, Here's My Brutally Honest ReviewToyota RAV4 Is The Most Satisfying New Compact SUV2026 Toyota RAV4ToyotaIn the new JD Power 2026 U.S. Automotive Performance, Execution and Layout (APEAL) Study, the RAV4 emerged as the most satisfying compact crossover. The study is based on a survey of thousands of owners following the first 90 days of ownership of a new vehicle. They're asked about virtually every aspect of the vehicle, including design, comfort, performance appeal, quality, and a lot more.AdvertisementAdvertisementThe compact crossover segment is intensely competitive, so the RAV4's accomplishment is particularly impressive. New for the 2026 model year, owners have clearly been won over by the Toyota's newly standard hybrid powertrain and more modern design. In the same category, the Nissan Rogue and Kia Sportage were the runners-up. Both have been around for a few years but have been updated over the course of their life cycles.2026 Nissan Rogue Rock Creek editionNissanView the 3 images of this gallery on the original articleThat leaves the CR-V without a podium finish, but it doesn't mean the Honda performed poorly; rivals simply impressed owners more over the first three months. As a brand, Honda only ranked 12th among mass-market automakers, just behind Toyota. Surprisingly, not a single Honda achieved a category win or runner-up finish. By contrast, Toyota had two category wins and three runner-up finishes.This study alone doesn't mean the CR-V is a bad option in its class, though.The CR-V Is In It For The Long Haul2026 Honda CR-V TrailSport HybridHondaThe APEAL study includes more emotional aspects of new-vehicle ownership such as design, advanced tech, and driving appeal. The CR-V has historically not been the flashiest or best-performing vehicle in its class, and the same is true of the current iteration. In base form, the 190-horsepower engine prioritizes economy over performance. The CR-V also has a rather conservative design, inside and out, which is why flashier rivals like the Sportage may be initially more appealing.AdvertisementAdvertisementIt's when you dig deeper that the Honda's attributes come to the fore. Build quality is unquestionably solid, and RepairPal ranked it second out of 26 compact SUVs for reliability. It also holds a large chunk of its original value after five years of ownership, making it a sound financial decision. In hybrid guise, economy is exceptional at up to 40 mpg combined.These strengths do not necessarily conjure up early excitement, but they add up over time, making the CR-V a smarter buy than most competitors.Related: 2026 Toyota RAV4 vs 2026 Honda CR-V Reliability: Which One Will Be More Reliable?This story was originally published by Autoblog on Jul 28, 2026, where it first appeared in the News section. Add Autoblog as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
+21 others
