If you walked into a Porsche dealership intent on buying a brand-new 2026 Cayenne GTS, you'd likely spend somewhere near $170k with a good deal of optional upgrades included. However, roughly $40,000 of that original value would be lost if you sold it just months later. For one unlucky original owner, this exact nightmare occurred. Porsche's Expensive Options Didn't Protect The Cayenne From Depreciation Load your Cayenne with as many options as you want – it won't matter in the end. Our example outlined above began its life as a $169,990 vehicle, stuffed with nearly $37,000 of optional extras. For context, a base-spec 2026 Cayenne GTS stickers at about $132,400 before any destination fees, taxes, or other costs are added into the mix. Some of those upgrades include the Sport Chrono package, Porsche's Dynamic Chassis Control, and what's called the Premium Plus package. Despite having a huge options list pushing the sticker price to nearly $170k, the used market had some bad news to deliver to its original owner. Once it finally sold – after just a few months of ownership – the bill of sale listed just $131,500, less than a base-spec Cayenne GTS. The unfortunate truth regarding optional extras and resale value comes down to personalization. For example, if one person prefers a certain type of leather or maybe the Sport Chrono package, their search is severely limited to a relative handful of cars. Because of this, the entire used market takes a dip, regardless. This is especially the case with certain performance, luxury, or ultra-luxury vehicles. Someone's red-on-red color combination may not be another person's cup of tea. The Sheer Amount Of Depreciation Created An Unusual Base-Price Inversion The total amount of time elapsed between the ill-fated $170k Cayenne GTS being bought new and sold used was just nine months. Its used sale price came in at $900 less than a brand-new base iteration – despite barely having the plastic taken off. Reportedly, the odometer only showed about 5,400 miles when the proverbial gavel fell. This isn't unique to this example, either. If you peruse a few Porsche dealerships around the country looking for a used '26 Cayenne GTS model, you'll find quite a few low-mileage examples for sale. Additionally, many of these carry Porsche certified pre-owned warranties, which can only be offered by franchised Porsche dealers. One example was recently listed for $142,441 with only 2,533 miles on the clock. According to JD Power, the average price paid for a 2026 Cayenne GTS on the used market is about $141,790, although other sources vary widely in terms of average pricing, with estimates swinging between roughly $120k and $160k. However, a few certified, low-mileage examples on the market are priced as low as $90,000, lending credence to the notion that luxury performance SUV used values seem to have a mind of their own. Even A Purpose-Built Performance SUV Can Be The Wrong Car Despite having a 493-horsepower twin-turbo V8, a 4.4-second 0–60 mph time, and the practicality of an SUV, a Cayenne GTS can still be the wrong car for its owner. According to the original owner of the $131,500 financial disaster model, they preferred an Alpina XB7 – a bespoke, heavily upgraded version of the BMW X7 – for family duties. The GTS itself draws from a broad range of elements across the Cayenne lineup. It sits in the upper-middle tier of the Cayenne lineup and combines substantial luxury with strong performance – including its 4.0-liter V8, a sport-tuned exhaust, and Race-Tex interior trimming – though buyers with large families who need something more comfortable or larger would likely be hard-pressed to make a Cayenne GTS work. When the ill-fated example first went up for sale, it was listed on Cars & Bids, where it failed to sell. The reserve price hadn't been met, and the highest bid was a meager $105,000. Once it was clear that an auction would not yield an agreeable price, the original owner sold it privately rather than continuing to pursue an auction sale. With a particular model that isn't well-known or universally sought-after, sometimes auctions can be its worst enemy. Certain cars appeal to only a select few buyers, and the Cayenne GTS seems to fall into that category. If the right buyer isn't scouring Cars & Bids during the time it's on the block, it may sell for much lower than it could. Opting for a private sale – as the owner decided to do – often allows the right buyer to come along at their own pace. The 911 Retains 94.7% Of Its Value – Making It The Anti-Cayenne While the Cayenne GTS may suffer from severe depreciation, some other Porsches simply do not. The 911 is arguably the best example, as it manages to retain roughly 94.7% of its value after five years, according to iSeeCars.com. Even more impressive, the 911 is cited as the best car to buy for resale value on the modern automotive market, as it suffers the least from depreciation. The Smartest Way To Buy A New Porsche Cayenne GTS: Don't Imagine taking about $140 in cash and throwing it into a blender. Now, repeat that ritual every day for nine months – that's how steep the ill-fated 2026 Porsche Cayenne GTS's depreciation was. Low miles didn't matter, its options list didn't matter, and even its powerful engine didn't really matter. The used car market isn't kind to models that don't offer lasting value for one reason or another, and it ate the Cayenne GTS for breakfast twice over. Those of you now considering a used Cayenne GTS can take a few tips away from this article: for one thing, it's important to distinguish between optional equipment that genuinely adds value versus personalization touches – like red leather or illuminated door sills with customized messages (yes, some dealers offer that). Also, it would be in your best interest to pursue a certified pre-owned Cayenne GTS. That way, you're getting a virtually new car with a factory-backed warranty that has already shed most of its worst depreciation through the original owner. However, if you have a specific color combination or similar preferences in mind, you may want to shop around for a while. Or, alternatively, keep your mind open. Most would agree that even settling for a less-than-perfect 2026 Cayenne GTS is better than losing $140 a day for the first nine months of a brand-new model's lifespan. Sources: Porsche, iSeeCars.com, Cars & Bids, JD Power.