The finance and insurance office must evolve to keep up with a new breed of customer — one with detailed research, pointed questions and price comparisons sharpened by artificial intelligence.
Customers are demanding transparency and faster negotiations. Sticking with the status quo risks losing the sale.
F&I offices are responding by training employees and using AI, while ensuring they comply with state and federal regulations.
“We have to evolve or die,” said Preston Stewart, national variable operations director and director of compliance for Napleton Automotive Group, based near Chicago.
CategoryFROM OUR DATA CENTER
Dealership group rankings based on new- and used-vehicle sales, used vehicle-only retailers, dealer census data and other dealer-related data
Image
Keeping up with customers’ changing priorities has become as important to sealing the deal as the transaction itself. Besides transparency and speed, they want assurancethat their purchase is the best deal for them ― even if that differs fromwhat AI tells them.
Consumers’ experience in F&I often determines how positively they view the entire purchase process, according to a June study from CDK Global.
The dealership technology company surveyed more than 1,000 consumers on their experience with the finance office. More than 8 in 10 said most of their time at the dealership was spent with an F&I manager, but 90 percent of respondents said they were satisfied with that interaction — a jump from 79 percent a year ago.
Consumers were more satisfied across the board compared with 2025, as more respondents said the F&I manager had good communication, offered recommendations that matched their needs and earned their trust.
Time matters, too: Satisfaction levels dropped from 93 percentif a customer spent less than a half hour in F&I, to 73 percent for visits of more than three hours.
Customers want more transparent, speedier transactions
Transparency is the key to accelerating the F&I process at Napleton, Stewart said.
Employees sell only the most appropriate product for a consumer, Stewart said. The groupde-emphasized optional credit life and credit disability coverage, for instance, because customers considered the products less valuable. The goal now is to be more transparent about what they truly need.
“Let’s get the customer in the office fast and present them with the best world-class presentation each time,” he said. “We’ll let the customer decide which option makes the best sense.”
Finance offices increasingly are using tablets and other electronic tools to visually present financing information, said Gary Bosses, senior vice president of dealer services at Assurant, an F&I product provider and trainer.
Assurant’s dealership customers can present the company’s extended warranty options to car buyers in person or remotely, and they respond well to the choice, Bosses said.
Dealerships that meet consumers’ requests for flexibility achieve higher sales and satisfaction scores, Bosses said.
Dealerships also are tapping providers such as Assurantto help process F&I deals during busy customer periods. Working with a tablet and video, those outside professionals can help customers complete their financing quickly, efficiently and within the necessary compliance framework, Bosses said.
Technology, training help F&I offices adapt
Ken Garff Automotive Group in Salt Lake Cityhas made complete pricing visible on its store websites. Its more than 200 F&I managers go through intensive training so they knowwhat customer disclosures are required for compliance, said Hayden Griffitts, the group’s lendingdirector.
Younger, AI-savvy customers sometimes sit down in the F&I office, record themselves negotiating with ChatGPT and start dealmaking based on those real-time answers, Griffitts said.
To keep up, the dealership group also usesAI in its training, he said. A platform that monitors customer interactions — with theirconsent — delivers rapid coaching feedback and is far more efficient than the hours managers once spent reviewing video recordings, he said.
It alsohelpsemployees answer customer questions,Griffitts said.
Napleton is piloting an AI-driven platform that coaches and monitors sales associates who, in turn, work with customers using AI, Stewart said.
AI chatbots mimic recent customer interactions, letting sales teams practice countering objections, he said. The tool also teaches employeesto ask key questions about financing basics to correct AI-generated errorsand misunderstandingscustomers might have.
“Let’s make sure it’s right and it’s the full information, so that the AI can give a good, real answer to the consumer and lead them down the right path,” Stewart said.
Compliance remains at the forefront in F&I process
Dealerships are emphasizing compliance as the Federal Trade Commission takes a tough stance on pricing transparency in advertising, including the disclosure of all required fees.
In addition, dealerships are required to safeguard customers’ sensitive personal and financial data.
Customers often must return to the dealership because of unsigned or missing F&I documents, Stewart said.
Napleton also uses AI to counter this. The technologyreviews finance packages to spot missing documents or signatures and other compliance gaps before customers leave, Stewart said. That means fewer buyers need to returnto correct paperwork problems.
“That supports both compliance and a smoother customer experience,” Stewart said.
Kunes Auto Group, with dealerships in Illinois, Wisconsin, Iowa and Minnesota, focuses on consistency. It offers straightforward education on all its products that complies withprivacy and disclosure laws, said Scot Hensel, its finance director.
“The consumer, especially with AI, has much more knowledge” aboutwhat to expect in the F&I office, Hensel said. “But we offer every product to every customer every time, to give them the option. That’s the best way to really be compliant.”
The AI tools that Napleton’s finance office uses are company-approved, with proper security and privacy safeguards, Stewart said. The group also encourages sales associates to use AI for lower-stakes tasks, such as developing new sales processes that don’t involve personal data.
“Our primary theme is removing friction without removing the human element,” Stewart said. “It’s teaching our people right now how to utilize AI to be their friend.”