After yet another year of criticism due to consistent underperformance and failure to meet expectations, Hendrick Motorsports surprisingly (yet also not surprisingly) opted to keep Chase Elliott paired with crew chief Alan Gustafson for the 2027 NASCAR Cup Series season.

The decision came even after the team switched things up on William Byron's No. 24 team, replacing Rudy Fugle with former O'Reilly Auto Parts Series crew chief Adam Wall.

Byron won just one race in 2026, after recording four straight years with multiple victories, and his eighth place points finish was his lowest since 2021. That said, under a Championship 4 format, he still would have been second in 2026, so the standings comparison is sort of apples to oranges.

As for Elliott, he continues to go backwards.

Excluding his winless 2023 season, in which he missed six races due to injury and one due to suspension, he set new career-lows in 2026 in top five finishes, top 10 finishes, laps led, points finish, and yes, average finish, which is the one stat that Gustafson defenders had pointed to from 2023 to 2025 even though the No. 9 team's performance had been nowhere near where it was to open up the Next Gen era in 2022. Elliott won five races and led the series in total points scored by a wide margin that year.

First and foremost, we don't envy Gustafson. As the crew chief for the sport's most popular driver and arguably its loudest and most passionate driver fanbase, he is always going to be the one getting the criticism when things don't go his driver's way, fair or not.

It's part of the reason why NASCAR tried to turn him into a folk hero when Elliott actually won at Martinsville Speedway after the No. 9 team's strategy call benefitted him due to a timely caution.

But for as much as Elliott can't be fully absolved from the blame for the team's struggles, this has been a consistent downward trend for years. This isn't just "one down year". This partnership has grown stale, and any other driver would have been paired with somebody new at this point.

Dale Earnhardt Jr. recently defended Gustafson and Hendrick Motorsports' decision to keep him paired with Elliott for a 12th season in 2027.

"There's this small little group of people that are seeing this news and going, 'They're going to leave Chase and Alan together still?' It's ridiculous. Chase and Alan want to work together. It's their [expletive] choice. None of y'all's business," Earnhardt said on his Dale Jr. Download podcast. "Chase likes it. He's said it multiple times. He likes Alan. What are we missing?"

In and of itself, it's a fair point. But from a big picture standpoint, this criticism misses the mark.

Earnhardt ignoring performance speaks louder than words

I think the question is more so about what Earnhardt is missing here. Again, this isn't just one bad season. This is a trend. The fact that they like working together is nice, and camaraderie is important, but there are times when so is being comfortable with being uncomfortable. Change can bring about that lack of comfort, but sometimes it's necessary for growth.

How many times does an NFL head coach get fired or a quarterback get traded simply because they don't like working together? It almost never exclusively comes down to that.

How many times does an employee get moved around or a boss get moved to a new role despite the two having a good working relationship? It happens all the time, and it usually doesn't take 12 years, either.

So why does the actual elephant in the room, this continued drop in performance, not seem to matter at all when it comes to the No. 9 team?

Earnhardt means well. He feels, like many fans do, for Gustafson, given the constant criticism he receives. But it reeks of complacency. "They get along" should not be the one and only reason to keep from making a change when the performance has declined and the standards are not being met. And they are consistently not being met.

It's time to get uncomfortable, rather than refuse to make a change simply because a consistently underperforming partnership isn't toxic. That cannot be the one and only determining factor. It's the lowest of low bars to clear.

There are teams with far lower standards than HMS that would have had no issue making a change years ago. It never would have even taken this long.

From mid-May at Watkins Glen International to mid-September at Bristol Motor Speedway, Elliott recorded two top 10 finishes in 18 races. That's half of a season. Every other playoff driver recorded at least four during that stretch, and Elliott's two tied him with the likes of John Hunter Nemechek (29th in points), Riley Herbst (30th), and Connor Zilisch (33rd). It put him behind Zane Smith (27th), along with nine others who failed to qualify for the postseason.

Even Alex Bowman, the team's so-called "weak link" who missed four races earlier in the year due to medical reasons, reeled off five top 10 finishes during that stretch.

Byron recorded seven, and Kyle Larson recorded 10. And let's not forget that, up until that point, those two were considered to have been "struggling" this season as well.

Meanwhile, Elliott was down there with two, bringing a whole new meaning to the word "struggle".

But hey, he and Gustafson get along, so we're supposed to believe it doesn't matter that they're running 17th every week, and the criticism is allegedly ridiculous. And it's supposedly not any of the fans' business to be frustrated with that?

This is Hendrick Motorsports we're talking about here. This kind of lack of performance should not be excused because "they like each other". Sometimes change is necessary to grow, and the fact that that is conveniently being ignored here is only going to make the problem worse. In some ways, it already has.

The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result. A championship-caliber team like HMS is effectively expecting more mediocrity in 2027, and they're evidently okay with it.

Earnhardt isn't wrong to want to defend Gustafson. But his defense is basely a very, very small part of a big picture that seemingly gets bleaker and bleaker for Elliott and the No. 9 team.