New material uncovered four years after his ouster as CEO at Nissan backs Ghosn’s claim that a post-retirement payment scheme had the support of top management and wouldn’t take effect without board approval.

documents surface supporting kelly’s, ghosn’s view of nissan overthrow
Getty Images

The fourth anniversary of the sensational arrest of Carlos Ghosn and Greg Kelly, the former No.1 and No.3 executives at Nissan, came and went last month with almost no media attention.

Ghosn, an industry legend for his role in saving the Japanese automaker from bankruptcy 19 years earlier, then building what came to be known as the Renault-Nissan-Mitsubishi Motors Alliance into a top global player, was arrested shortly after his arrival at a Tokyo airport on Nov. 19, 2018. Thirteen months later he would make a dramatic escape to his native Lebanon, where he lives today in exile, a wanted man.

Kelly, an American who was lured back to Japan on false pretenses shortly before the Thanksgiving holiday in 2018, would spend the next three and a half years there where he stood trial and, finally, with the support of the White House and State Department, was able to leave last March. His verdict – not guilty on seven out of eight counts – is being appealed.

Documents we’ve obtained, several provided by Ghosn, show categorically that Kelly was falsely accused. Among the documentation, first published by Asia Times:

Greg Kelly, Hiroto Saikawa and Scott Becker future compensation and employment proposal for Ghosn; Nov. 21, 2011. Greg Kelly, Hiroto Saikawa, Latham & Watkins LLP lawyers and Hari Nada future compensation proposals for Ghosn: Proposal 1 Oct. 28, 2013, and Proposal 2 June 23, 2015. Latham & Watkins LLP interview with Hari Nada (July 3, 2019) in which Nada, who headed the CEO’s office and was one of Ghosn’s and Kelly’s main accusers, reveals Kelly’s and possibly Ghosn’s innocence, noting during Kelly’s trial, the chief judge, aware that Nissan or the Tokyo prosecutors’ office had withheld a key document from the defense, wouldn’t allow its admittance. Thierry Bolloré’s whistle-blowing memo to Nissan’s board to investigate the coup, Hari Nada’s alleged criminality and the removal of Christina Murray, Nissan’s global compliance officer, from her role as head of the internal investigation. Bolloré, at the time CEO of Renault, would be fired by Renault’s board three days later on Oct. 11, 2019.

Ghosn’s case is more complicated because he was CEO at the time of the alleged crime of concealing eight years of future income – from March 2011, of ¥9.3 billion ($94 million). Unfortunately for him, the buck stops with the CEO.

Nevertheless, in March 2011, when Nissan’s secretariat began tracking “lost income” for Ghosn, the newly disclosed document  kept secret from the public by Nissan management, shows Ghosn acted on the advice of his two most senior Japanese advisors, Toshiyuki Shiga and Itaru Koeda, not Kelly.

Shiga at the time was chief operating officer. Koeda was a former co-chairman. Both advised Ghosn there was “no legal problem” with the secretariat keeping a running tally of his income shortfall – Ghosn had taken a 50% pay cut the previous year and was trying to find a way to reclaim those lost wages. Importantly, they also told him he wouldn’t have to disclose the secretariat’s record until his retirement and only if the board hired him as an advisor and approved a post-retirement advisory contract.

Kelly wasn’t involved with these discussions. In fact, Kelly had advised Ghosn he couldn’t reclaim lost income. Initially, he turned to Nissan North America’s general counsel, Scott Becker, who wrote several legal opinions and then collaborated with Hiroto Saikawa, who would become Ghosn’s successor as CEO.

As noted above, Saikawa signed four proposals – two in 2011 and one each in 2013 and 2015, the latter two signed with Kelly, all written by lawyers, all offering Ghosn future advisory/consulting work and all including wording to prevent him from working for a competitor. There was not a single mention of the secretariat’s keeping a running tally.

GM and Ford had both offered Ghosn jobs, eliciting concerns that he might jump ship.

Although we haven’t seen the original Shiga-Koeda documents, the report by Nissan’s internal investigation headed by Murray and titled “Kali 10 Compensation Investigation Report,” confirms their existence. Buried in the findings, as note above, are the following passages:

“Internal documents confirm that there was a discussion between Toshiaki Ohnuma (general manager of the secretariat), Shiga and Koeda in March 2011 concerning payment of the Haircut (salary shortfall) to Ghosn.

“A proposal by Shiga and Koeda dated March 16, 2011 titled ‘Payment for CEO, Proposal by SK’ lists three options for payment of the Haircut: (a) as incentive compensation paid after retirement without disclosure, (b) as a retirement allowance with disclosure and (c) as an advisor fee paid 1-2 years after retirement without disclosure.”

Note the words: “without disclosure.”

This was a key element in the charges against Ghosn and Kelly – that they made false statements in Nissan’s annual securities reports by not disclosing, thus underreporting part of Ghosn’s future income. Except, they didn’t indict the two senior Japanese who told him it was legal.

The report continues:

“On March 18, 2011, Ohnuma prepared a memorandum for Shiga and Koeda to present to Ghosn based on option (c), and on March 23, 2011, Koeda instructed Ohnuma to revise the memorandum (and) proposed to pay the Haircut as an advisor or consultant fee after Ghosn’s retirement…

“The memorandum further states that board approval would be required for payment of the fee. Shiga told us that he insisted on this requirement because he thought that board approval would cure any potential impropriety with the arrangement. The email correspondence indicates that Shiga and Koeda presented the plan to Ghosn on March 28, 2011.

Ghosn has always asserted that “board approval” was necessary. This document supports that contention.

So where does that leave Nissan and Renault four years after an anti-Ghosn faction inside Nissan, operating in secret from the board, removed him from management?

The automakers have seen their global market shares decline, in Nissan’s case by two percentage points. Although they are both profitable again, margins are substantially lower than they were during most of the Ghosn years and most global OEMs today.

Combined they have lost $33 billion in market capitalization. Counting Mitsubishi, which joined the Alliance in 2016, the total comes to $36 billion.

Meanwhile, the purge that followed Ghosn’s ouster, coupled with a restructuring of Nissan’s board, bringing in a majority of directors with little or no automotive experience, has left the automaker with a weak management bench.

The biggest losses: José Muñoz, who left Nissan to join Hyundai as COO, and Christian Meunier, brand CEO at Jeep.

The Alliance is unraveling in plain sight. Renault is looking for new partners, having recently signed a “framework” agreement with China’s Geely to focus on conventional and hybrid cars.

The automaker needs cash to finance its battery-electric-vehicle business and have a chance to compete in its main market, Europe. Nissan no longer is considered a good fit, having fallen out of the top 15 in BEV sales.

Much of the recent reporting in Europe centers on the possibility of Renault unloading a chunk of its 42% stake in Nissan, probably taking it down to 15%.

And then, whether the Alliance will continue.

Keyword: Documents Surface Supporting Kelly’s, Ghosn’s View of Nissan Overthrow

CAR'S NEWS RELATED

Made-in-India Nissan Magnite AMT launched in South Africa

Nissan offers three variants of the Magnite AMT in South Africa: Visia, Acenta and Acenta Plus, priced from R234,900. Nissan has launched the Magnite AMT in South Africa. The crossover will be manufactured at the brand’s Oragadam factory near Chennai. Nissan offers three variants of the Magnite AMT in ...

View more: Made-in-India Nissan Magnite AMT launched in South Africa

Next-Gen Nissan Juke And Qashqai EVs To Be Made In The UK: Report

UK media claim Nissan will announce on Friday that its Sunderland plant will make future all-electric Juke and Qashqai SUVs.

View more: Next-Gen Nissan Juke And Qashqai EVs To Be Made In The UK: Report

Automatic crossovers competing against the new Nissan Magnite EZ-Shift

What’s available The competitors Renault Kiger 1.0 Zen auto Suzuki Ignis 1.2 GLX auto Suzuki Fronx 1.5 GL auto Chery Tiggo 4 Pro 1.5 LiT auto The most affordable automatic crossovers from other brands Kia Sonet 1.5 LX auto Toyota Urban Cruiser 1.5 XR auto Haval Jolion 1.5T Premium ...

View more: Automatic crossovers competing against the new Nissan Magnite EZ-Shift

Nissan to build electric versions of two best-selling crossovers, the Juke and Qashqai

Nissan plans to build electric versions for two of its best-selling crossovers in the UK. According to a new report, Nissan will build an electric Juke and Qashqai at its Sunderland factory. The report from Sky News Wednesday claims Nissan will announce the new electric crossovers on Friday. Citing ...

View more: Nissan to build electric versions of two best-selling crossovers, the Juke and Qashqai

Researchers are recycling old Nissan Leaf batteries using… bacteria?

Researchers at the University of Edinburgh in Scotland are investigating a method to recover the metallic content of batteries with engineered bacteria. The new method involves processing spent Nissan Leaf batteries into a “leachate” — a liquified battery slurry — and combining that slurry with said microbes. The method ...

View more: Researchers are recycling old Nissan Leaf batteries using… bacteria?

Honda and Nissan slash rates to keep pace with BYD, EVs in overseas markets

Japanese automakers are scrambling to avoid being squeezed out of the market by BYD and other Chinese EVs. Honda and Nissan are the latest to slash rates in overseas markets to boost demand. It’s no secret that Japanese automakers are some of the biggest laggards as the industry transitions ...

View more: Honda and Nissan slash rates to keep pace with BYD, EVs in overseas markets

List of museums & factory tours every petrolhead must go to

Here’s a list of 13 museums every auto enthusiast must visit. BHPian JDMBOI recently shared this with other enthusiasts. Here is a list of museums & factory tours every petrol-head must go to, so fasten your seat belt and grab some drink because it’s going to be a long ...

View more: List of museums & factory tours every petrolhead must go to

Most affordable crossover from every brand in South Africa

A dominant force Alfa Romeo Tonale Audi Q2 BAIC Beijing X55 BMW X2 BYD Atto 3 Chery Tiggo 4 Pro Citroen C3 Fiat 500X Ford Puma Haval Jolion Honda WR-V Hyundai Venue Jaguar E-Pace Jeep Renegade Kia Sonet Mahindra XUV300 Lexus UX Maserati Grecale Mazda CX-3 Mercedes-Benz GLA MINI ...

View more: Most affordable crossover from every brand in South Africa

Tesla, Audi, And Nissan EVs Have Minimal Winter Range Loss

R400,000 single cabs competing with the new Mahindra Pik Up Karoo

Throwback Thursday: The BenSopra Nardó Special 380SX

Nissan Magnite AMT Becomes Most Affordable Auto SUV in SA

New Nissan Magnite EZ-Shift now on sale – The most affordable two-pedal SUV in South Africa

Nissan wants to build a Ford Ranger Raptor rival

Nissan's $250 Nismo Pajamas Will Help You Catch More Zzzs

This 1998 Nissan Stagea 260RS Autech Is The Skyline GT-R Station Wagon That Nissan Refused To Build

The Nissan Stagea 260RS Autech Version Is A Skyline GT-R Wagon

Nissan Magnite AMT introductory pricing extended till Nov 30

R530,000 SUVs that rival the new Chery Tiggo 7 Pro Max

Throwback Thursday: The Liberty Walk R35

OTHER CAR NEWS

; Top List in the World https://www.pinterest.com/newstopcar/pins/
Top Best Sushi Restaurants in SeoulTop Best Caribbean HoneymoonsTop Most Beautiful Islands in PeruTop Best Outdoor Grill BrandsTop Best Global Seafood RestaurantsTop Foods to Boost Your Immune SystemTop Best Foods to Fight HemorrhoidsTop Foods That Pack More Potassium Than a BananaTop Best Healthy Foods to Gain Weight FastTop Best Cosmetic Brands in the U.STop Best Destinations for Food Lovers in EuropeTop Best Foods High in Vitamin ATop Best Foods to Lower Your Blood SugarTop Best Things to Do in LouisianaTop Best Cities to Visit in New YorkTop Best Makeup Addresses In PennsylvaniaTop Reasons to Visit NorwayTop Most Beautiful Islands In The WorldTop Best Law Universities in the WorldTop Richest Sportsmen In The WorldTop Biggest Aquariums In The WorldTop Best Peruvian Restaurants In MiamiTop Best Road Trips From MiamiTop Best Places to Visit in MarylandTop Best Places to Visit in North CarolinaTop Best Electric Cars For KidsTop Best Swedish Brands in The USTop Best Skincare Brands in AmericaTop Best American Lipstick BrandsTop Michelin-starred Restaurants in MiamiTop Best Secluded Getaways From MiamiTop Best Things To Do On A Rainy Day In MiamiTop Most Instagrammable Places In MiamiTop Interesting Facts about FlorenceTop Facts About The First Roman Emperor - AugustusTop Best Japanese FoodsTop Most Beautiful Historical Sites in IsraelTop Best Places To Visit In Holy SeeTop Best Hawaiian IslandsTop Reasons to Visit PortugalTop Best Hotels In L.A. With Free Wi-FiTop Best Scenic Drives in MiamiTop Best Vegan Restaurants in BerlinTop Most Interesting Attractions In WalesTop Health Benefits of a Vegan DietTop Best Thai Restaurant in Las VegasTop Most Beautiful Forests in SwitzerlandTop Best Global Universities in GermanyTop Most Beautiful Lakes in GuyanaTop Best Things To Do in IdahoTop Things to Know Before Traveling to North MacedoniaTop Best German Sunglasses BrandsTop Highest Mountains In FranceTop Biggest Hydroelectric Plants in AmericaTop Best Spa Hotels in NYCTop The World's Scariest BridgeTop Largest Hotels In AmericaTop Most Famous Festivals in JordanTop Best European Restaurants in MunichTop Best Japanese Hiking Boot BrandsTop Best Universities in PolandTop Best Tips for Surfing the Web Safely and AnonymouslyTop Most Valuable Football Clubs in EuropeTop Highest Mountains In ColombiaTop Real-Life Characters of Texas RisingTop Best Beaches in GuatelamaTop Things About DR Congo You Should KnowTop Best Korean Reality & Variety ShowsTop Best RockstarsTop Most Beautiful Waterfalls in GermanyTop Best Fountain Pen Ink BrandsTop Best European Restaurants in ChicagoTop Best Fighter Jets in the WorldTop Best Three-Wheel MotorcyclesTop Most Beautiful Lakes in ManitobaTop Best Dive Sites in VenezuelaTop Best Websites For Art StudentsTop Best Japanese Instant Noodle BrandsTop Best Comedy Manhwa (Webtoons)Top Best Japanese Sunglasses BrandsTop Most Expensive Air Jordan SneakersTop Health Benefits of CucumberTop Famous Universities in SwedenTop Most Popular Films Starring Jo Jung-sukTop Interesting Facts about CougarsTop Best Hospitals for Hip Replacement in the USATop Most Expensive DefendersTop Health Benefits of GooseberriesTop Health Benefits of ParsnipsTop Best Foods and Drinks in LondonTop Health Benefits of Rosehip TeaTop Best Air Fryers for Low-fat CookingTop Most Asked Teacher Interview Questions with AnswersTop Best Shopping Malls in ZurichTop The Most Beautiful Botanical Gardens In L.A.Top Best Mexican Restaurants in Miami for Carb-loading rightTop Best Energy Companies in GermanyTop Best Garage HeatersTop Largest Banks in IrelandTop Leading Provider - Audit and Assurance In The USTop Best Jewelry Brands in IndiaTop Prettiest Streets in the UKTop Best Lakes to Visit in TunisiaTop Highest Mountains in Israel