guides, mini, automotive design, cars, motoring, a minimal motoring manifesto

A couple of years ago, Hackaday published an article, “Electric Vehicles Continue the Same Wasteful Mistakes That Limit Longevity“, in which we took a look at the way the car industry, instead of taking the move to electric traction as an opportunity to simplify their products, was instead making their electric offerings far more complex. It touched a nerve and received a very large comment volume, such that now it is our 19th most commented story of all time.

It’s something brought back to the fore by seeing a The Drive piece bemoaning the evolution of the automobile as a software receptacle governed by end-user licenses rather than a machine under the control of its owner. In turn that’s posed the question: Just what do you really need for a car, and what is superfluous? Time to provide an answer to that question, so here it is: a minimal motoring manifesto.

It’s The Subsystems, Not The Design

The mechanical parts of a motor vehicle are by and large a done deal. We worked out long ago how to make motor vehicles that don’t decay in a short time, that have reliable mechanics, are safe to use, and handle well on the road. The front-wheel-drive car with transverse motor and transmission, a wheel as close to each corner as it can be, and independent suspension all round has been a staple on the road since the 1970s, and the probability is high that one will be sitting on your driveway.

It matters not whether it has an internal combustion engine or an electric motor, over time it has evolved to offer exceptional crash protection and a reasonable weight. Thus this is not about the physical and mechanical design of a motor vehicle, instead it concerns the subsystems that run the show. In a world where engines don’t break at 100,000 miles and it’s not uncommon to see two-decade-old cars with no rust, it’s these subsystems which will make the difference between a car under the control of its owner and one which makes an early exit to the scrapyard.

Separate The Subsystems

A Lucas engine management system from the 1990s. ColinMB, CC BY-SA 3.0

In every motor vehicle, there are different systems responsible for their respective tasks. Sometime these are integral to the safety or operation of the car such as the engine management or the antilock braking, other times they are not, such as the air conditioning or the entertainment system. The former are essential, the latter are toys to entice would-be owners to buy the cars.

We get it that a new car buyer wants plenty of toys to brag about and feel good about their purchase, but at the same time the extra complexity brought about by those toys should not be the reason for a car with plenty of life left in it to come off the road a few years later. So here’s the first manifesto point: separate the toys from the essential stuff such that whatever runs the toys is not mission critical to the operation of the vehicle, and is not governed by subscription or software licensing terms. By all means have the navigation system disappear when the app goes to abandonware, but this should not come at the expense of the car’s being able to operate.

Provide A Minimal Way In

The OBD interface provides a way in, but not the one that’s needed. Losch, CC BY 3.0

The saddest thing about walking round a scrap yard here in 2022 is that where once there would have been plenty of worn-out cars, today there are as many near-perfect cars. The computing power behind those toys for the person who drives it off the forecourt is a technological tour de force, but that’s of scant comfort to whoever owns it at ten years old who is faced with a bill for its replacement.

We understand that the manufacturer wants to build planned obsolescence into their products, but at the same time it’s for them to make better cars without resorting to dirty tricks. It should not be beyond the bounds of technical possibility to have a standard interface with enough capabilities for third party electronics to provide those essential functions to keep the vehicle going.

Here’s A Novel Idea…

Would anyone like to claim that minimalism can’t be fun to drive? Neozoon, CC BY-SA 3.0

We mentioned earlier that to some extent automotive design is a done deal, in that the transverse engined front wheel drive vehicle is king. Of course owners of RWD vehicles will chime in below in the comments, but it’s fair to say that with not many exceptions there’s surprisingly little difference between models.

A VW and a Ford and a Nissan feel so much like the same car in a way that their equivalents from several decades ago wouldn’t have, so the differentiating factors come down to the details. So desperate are they to differentiate themselves, that to distract from the blandness of the driving experience they instead concentrate on the experience of being in the car. It’s been such an insidious process as to be almost invisible, but should you try sitting in a car from decades past you’ll immediately see the difference. The older car has very little to distract the motorist, it’s a much less cluttered experience.

So here’s a novel idea, how about starting the design process from a point of view that less is more, and creating vehicles with the minimum required for them to be driven, because they are simply fun to drive? Perhaps people have forgotten even that driving can be fun.

Of Crooks And Dreamers

Of course, we know that this grandiosely-titled manifesto is simply a collection of ideas, and that no manufacturer will act on them. I once heard the adage that there were two types of small-production motor manufacturer, either crooks or dreamers, and I’m guessing that puts this article firmly in the land of dreamers.

But watching motor vehicles as an enthusiast sometimes feels like being an outsider in your own world, while everyone is gushing about the in-car entertainment system and you’re wondering why they don’t seem worried about its longevity or that the utilitarian styling cues aren’t matched by any pretence of ability away from the school run. We may be living in late-stage automobile design, but that doesn’t mean we have to like it.

Header image: Unknown author/public domain.

Keyword: A Minimal Motoring Manifesto

CAR'S NEWS RELATED

Bugatti Baby II Configurator Lets You Personalize MIni-Type 35 At Home

You can choose from three versions: Base, Vitesse, and Pur Sang.

View more: Bugatti Baby II Configurator Lets You Personalize MIni-Type 35 At Home

GM buys stake in lithium mining company to meet future EV demand

General Motors (GM) announced today that it would make an equity investment of $650 million with Lithium Americas to extract lithium at the Thackers Pass mine in Nevada. GM has set a renewed and aggressive EV production goal by introducing its first EV models following the Chevrolet Bolt, Bolt EUV, ...

View more: GM buys stake in lithium mining company to meet future EV demand

Pre-owned luxury cars under RM150k - what are your options?

The Malaysian automotive market has a wide variety of luxury cars from virtually all automakers, but a pre-owned model can sometimes make more sense to purchase, especially for those who want to watch their spending. Because luxury cars tend to get their biggest hit in depreciation in the first few ...

View more: Pre-owned luxury cars under RM150k - what are your options?

The 4 Most Reliable Mini Cooper Model Years You Can Buy

2021 Mini Cooper 2016 Mini Cooper 2011 Mini Cooper 2006 Mini Cooper Are Mini Coopers worth buying? If you’re shopping for a thrifty small car with plenty of character, consider the Mini Cooper. The British-made Cooper has been around for 60 years, and the charismatic little car recently celebrated ...

View more: The 4 Most Reliable Mini Cooper Model Years You Can Buy

FIRST LOOK: GRT Yamaha unveil 2023 WorldSBK machine for Remy Gardner, Dominique Aegerter

GRT Yamaha have officially taken the covers off their 2023 WorldSBK machine as Dominique Aegerter and Remy Gardner get set for their second pre-season test of the year. After making their WorldSBK debut during the final test of 2022, which was also at Jerez, Aegerter and Gardner were back ...

View more: FIRST LOOK: GRT Yamaha unveil 2023 WorldSBK machine for Remy Gardner, Dominique Aegerter

Elon Musk Meets With Biden Administration To Discuss EV Strategy

Tesla's CEO has had several run-ins with Biden in the past.

View more: Elon Musk Meets With Biden Administration To Discuss EV Strategy

Elon Musk meets with top Biden administration officials over electrification

Elon Musk has met today with top Biden administration officials over electrification goals and amid tensions between Musk, Tesla, and the administration. There have been a lot of tensions between the Biden administration, Tesla, and its CEO Musk and his fans. The first major blow seems to have been ...

View more: Elon Musk meets with top Biden administration officials over electrification

Biden-Harris administration announces availability of nearly $1.7 billion to modernize fleets and deploy clean transit buses across America

Second year of Bipartisan Infrastructure Law funding will enable communities nationwide to support transit worker training and create clean transit systems

View more: Biden-Harris administration announces availability of nearly $1.7 billion to modernize fleets and deploy clean transit buses across America

‘I was so bad’ – Vettel reminisces about shock simrace cameo

Jerez WorldSBK Test Results: Toprak Razgatlioglu top as Dominique Aegerter shines

4 Things U.S. News Doesn’t Like About the 2022 MINI Cooper

What Do the Letters Mini Stand For?

Lost in space: sleeping overnight in the Mini Urbanaut concept

Britishvolt UK gigafactory battery plan collapses into administration

The world’s smartest drivers can be found behind the wheel of these cars

Every electric car on sale in South Africa at the start of 2023

mReview: 2022 MINI Cooper Electric Resolute Edition - One Conflicted Cooper

Over 10% of vehicle sales for BMW Group Malaysia are ELECTRIC

Biden administration officials tout EVs at DC auto show

Stellantis recalls 76,000 plug-in hybrid minivans over engine issue

OTHER CAR NEWS

; Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự